AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - March 20, 2009

 
Allegany
B., BOBBIE S, MTR. OF350CAF 08-00967(NN-0726-07)
B., BOBBIE S, MTR. OF354CAF 08-00695(NN-0726-07)
HIXSON, MICHAEL A. v COTTON-HANLON, INC.,67CA 08-01864(32555)
 
Cattaraugus
BONAFEDE, DANIEL J. v STATE OF NEW YORK,362CA 08-01399(110353)
BOWEN, DONALD, PEOPLE v171KA 07-02095(I06-176)
GREY, JOHN v FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH OF OLEAN,431CA 08-01668(67998)
GREY, JOHN S. v FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH OF OLEAN, YORK432CA 08-01636(67998)
HOWELL, RAHEIM, PEOPLE v262KA 08-00236(I07-73)
LAFFERTY, ROBERT A., PEOPLE v169KA 06-01553(I05-008)
RICKICKI, DAVID P. v BORDEN CHEMICAL DIVISION OF BORDEN,22.2CA 07-01668(53395)
RICKICKI, DAVID P. v BORDEN CHEMICAL DIVISION OF BORDEN,22.1CA 07-02552(53395)
SAMPSON, P. MARC v RAINBOW FORD LINCOLN MERCURY, INC.,315CA 08-01956(66281)
WAGNER, WILLIAM G., PEOPLE v331KA 07-01782(I04-037)
 
Cayuga
CASE, ROBERT VERLE v CAYUGA COUNTY,1598CA 07-01351(06-867)
COYNE, SEAN P. v FISHER, BRIAN283TP 08-02113(2008-0489)
HOLBERT, STEPHEN M., PEOPLE v463KA 08-01127(I2006-147)
LANFAIR, GERALD v CORCORAN, MICHAEL268KAH 08-00831(2007-0918)
RAYMOND, ELWOOD L., PEOPLE v415KA 08-00516(I2007-059)
RICHARDS, MAGDALEN v BARTHOLOMEW, ANGELA481CA 06-02384(03-719)
 
Erie
A., SARAH, MTR. OF62CAF 08-00265(B-21281-06)
ABUHAMRA, IBITSAM TAHER v NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL FIRE, INSURANCE COMPANY1514CA 08-01178(2006/9242)
ALEJANDRO, JASON J., PEOPLE v391KA 08-00346(I2006-1820)
APPLETON, ROOSEVELT, PEOPLE v399KA 07-02352(I2006-1284)
B., LUCAS, MTR. OF271CAF 08-00181(B-02507-07)
BUSCH, JR., JAMES E., PEOPLE v438KA 07-01045(I02017-2006)
C., ELEGANT R., MTR. OF402CAF 08-00990(B-15613-07)
CARVALHO, ANTONIO R., PEOPLE v439KA 07-01683(I2005-2772)
D.R. WATSON HOLDINGS, LLC, CB RICHARD ELLIS, BUFFALO, LLC, v1357CA 08-01022(10299/2005)
DIPASQUALE, JACK L. v M.J. OGIONY BUILDERS, INC.,227CA 08-01642(I2006-2716)
FOXWORTH, MARGARETTA v JENKINS, JOHN112CA 08-01177(I2005-10751)
GOODMAN, COLLYER v BERBARY, JAMES L.284TP 08-02052(2007-11976)
GORDON, EBONY, PEOPLE v305KA 06-03028(I2005-1312)
GREEN, DARNELL, PEOPLE v172KA 07-01166(I2006-1052)
HAY, GERALD v JAY, GORDON360CA 08-01115(2002/253)
HORTON, ROBERT, PEOPLE v414KA 07-00239(S26747)
HUNT, DAVON, PEOPLE v329KA 08-00126(I2007-0122)
HUNT, DAVON, PEOPLE v328KA 08-00125(I2006-2816)
HYLANT, JOSEPH P. v MANUFACTURERS AND TRADERS TRUST, COMPANY335CA 08-00918(2003-2536)
JOHNSON, TERRANCE, PEOPLE v441KA 07-02677(I00031-2007)
JONES, DEVON, PEOPLE v467KA 08-00381(I2007-1466)
KMIOTEK, DEANNA M. v CHABA, GENE M.64CA 07-02403(2005-5030)
KONOPCZYNSKI, TODD v ADF CONSTRUCTION CORP.,161CA 08-01124(2004 9115)
L., JEFFREY, PEOPLE v325KA 07-02486(S28843)
LAIDLAW ENERGY & ENVIRONMENTAL, INC, v TOWN OF ELLICOTTVILLE,41CA 08-01624(2007-6628)
LEDWIN, ROY v AUMAN, JEFFREY182CA 08-01754(I-2002-9477)
MROZ, KENNETH, PEOPLE v324KA 08-00418(S28334)
O'CONNELL MACHINERY CO., INC., v CITY OF BUFFALO ZONING BOARD OF, APPEALS274CA 08-01281(I2007/10168)
P., MORGAN, MTR. OF314CAF 07-02411(NN-15576-06, O-14821/22-
POTTER, MARGARET M. v TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF, AURORA209.2CA 08-01967(I2008-9036)
POTTER, MARGARET M. v TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF AURORA,209.1CA 08-01727(I2008-2099)
RAAB, JAMIE v KALEIDA HEALTH,384CA 08-01352(2006-004013)
RAK, CAROLYN v COUNTRY FAIR, INC.,132CA 08-01656(2003-7234)
RAMOS, JUAN, PEOPLE v168KA 07-02190(I2006-1492)
RAULS, BRIAN v DIRECTV, INC.,224CA 08-01814(I2007-2770)
RICHMOND FARMS DAIRY, LLC, v NATIONAL GRANGE MUTUAL INSURANCE, COMPANY1556CA 08-01150(2006-2625)
RITE AID OF NEW YORK, INC., v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN,1602TP 08-01106(I 2007-4597)
S., EDDIE, MTR. OF492CAF 08-00038(B-3684-07, B-3685-07)
S., ISIS, MTR. OF401CAF 08-00251(B-02347-07)
SCISSION, RASHAD, PEOPLE v427KA 08-00124(I2006-2630)
SCOTT, GREG, PEOPLE v444KA 08-00792(I2006-1215)
VASQUEZ, JUSTIN, PEOPLE v488KA 08-00857(S26980)
VAZQUEZ, BILLY, PEOPLE v348KA 06-03657(I2005-2311-SAG)
VIBO CORPORATION, v WHITE, ERIC R.279CA 08-02177(2005/2478)
WEBB, LEON, PEOPLE v54KA 07-01914(I01901-2006)
WINTERS, JAKE, PEOPLE v423KA 08-00639(I2007-0935)
 
Genesee
GLADDING, NOAH, PEOPLE v469KA 07-00692(I4816)
GUTZMER, CARL A. v SANTINI, MYRIAM L.63CAF 08-00771(V-00039-98/07U,)
HARDY, JR., EDWARD W., PEOPLE v309KA 07-01890(S04-78)
OBERLANDER, ALEXIS, PEOPLE v53KA 07-01035(I4933)
W., DAKOTA, MTR. OF493CAF 07-02493(B-114-07)
 
Jefferson
ESTRELLITA LLC, v TOWN BOARD OF TOWN OF ALEXANDRIA,317CA 08-01948(2007-2022)
FLINN, GUNTHER J., PEOPLE v104KA 08-00440(I06-434-06)
MILLER, JOHN E. v LARGETT, JOHN J.480CA 08-00295(05-2377)
WIND POWER ETHICS GROUP, v ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS OF TOWN OF,34CA 07-01995(07-789)
WIND POWER ETHICS GROUP, v ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS,35CA 08-01409(07-0789)
 
Lewis
HEARTWOOD FORESTLAND FUND, III, LP, v CROOKED LAKE PRESERVE, LLC,1684CA 08-01307(CA2006-00010)
 
Livingston
CLOUTIER, PAUL G. v GENESEO COLLISION SERVICES, LLC,294CA 08-01992(9732003)
CRUZ, MARIA L. v CRUZ, SR., PEDRO L.311CAF 07-01584(V-00558-05/06A, V-00558-
MULHOLLAND, ATHENA v BOSS, TODD A.490CAF 08-01279(V-00343-02/06,)
NEVAREZ, JOHN v HUNT, CARL B.282TP 08-01569(77-2008)
WOOD, SCOTT M., PEOPLE v266KA 07-02337(I2002-049)
 
Monroe
1440 EMPIRE BOULEVARD DEVELOPMENT, CORP. v LAWYERS TITLE INSURANCE CORPORATION,275CA 08-01390(2006/06967)
ALLEN, CARLTON, PEOPLE v345KA 06-03416(W3615/06)
B., MAKAIO L., MTR. OF352CAF 07-02292(B-3882/83-07)
CHESHER, DARRELL J., PEOPLE v370KA 06-02854(W2006/3048)
CHILDRES, MIA CARL, PEOPLE v31KA 03-02632(I466/03)
CLOSURE, CURTIS, PEOPLE v390KA 07-00621(S2006/4187)
CLOSURE, CURTIS, PEOPLE v389KA 07-00620(S2006/4188)
CONLEY, KEVIN v NEVISON, MARLENE272CAF 08-01094(V-7524-07)
COTTO, EFRAIN, PEOPLE v153KA 05-02215(I484/05)
DOUGLAS, GOLDDE, PEOPLE v377KA 05-01759(I2004-0254)
FAIRPORT BAPTIST HOMES, v DAINES, M.D., RICHARD F.280TP 08-01974(07-5592)
GARCIA-SANTIAGO, JERRY L., PEOPLE v398KA 06-02142(I2005-0116)
HOYTE, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v306KA 06-01051(W2006-3014)
JOHNSON, DAVID M. v EBIDENERGY, INC.,1578CA 08-01455(2003-3167)
JONES, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v105KA 05-00667(I8/04)
JONES, TIM, PEOPLE v261KA 08-00801(S2006-3473)
KUNSMAN, EILEEN v BAROODY, RONALD343CA 08-02040(2006-0253)
MARTINEZ, ANGEL, PEOPLE v260KA 06-00121(I95-609)
NORTHERN TRUST, NA, v DELLEY, PATRICIA A.250CA 07-02360(07/2083)
OSBORNE, CHRISTOPHER H., PEOPLE v148KA 07-02262(I2004-1037)
PULLUAIM, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v369KA 06-02487(I650/05)
RESIDENTS AGAINST WAL-MART, v PLANNING BOARD OF TOWN OF, GREECE248CA 08-01662(07-13449)
RIVERA, ORLANDO, PEOPLE v425KA 05-02505(I198/05)
ROMAN, JOSE, PEOPLE v1561KA 03-01577(I561/02)
ROMAN, JOSE, PEOPLE v1560KA 03-01576(I514/02)
SANTOS, PEDRO M., PEOPLE v307KA 06-02806(S2005-3960)
SAPP, JEFFERY C., PEOPLE v349KA 06-00550(I539/05)
SHUFELT, JEANINE M. v DICE AMERICA, INC.,276CA 08-01721(2005/05359)
SIMMONS, JUACQUIS, PEOPLE v347KA 07-02287(I2004-197)
SMITH, JOB, PEOPLE v332KA 05-02007(I810/04)
SUMMERS, JOHN M. v CITY OF ROCHESTER,14CA 08-01032(2007-10556)
SUMMERS, JOHN M. v CITY OF ROCHESTER,15CA 08-01048(2007-10556)
WALLACE, KENNETH, PEOPLE v12KA 05-01408(I2004-1017)
YOUNG, BRANDON D., PEOPLE v466KA 07-00907(I2006-4125)
 
Niagara
BRADIGAN, WILLIAM M., PEOPLE v346KA 08-00517(I2006-589)
BRAND, SHAWN, PEOPLE v396KA 08-00146(I2005-526)
BUTLER, CHRISTIAN M., PEOPLE v483KA 08-00828(I2004-279)
MARACLE, TRACY, PEOPLE v209.4KA 07-02636(I2004-310)
MARACLE, TRACY, PEOPLE v209.3KA 07-00835(I2004-310)
RICKARD, IDA, PEOPLE v326KA 08-00846(I2004-419-V)
RODGERS, ANA v CITY OF NORTH TONAWANDA,383CA 08-02104(131393)
SOFIEN, LILLIAN v NOEL, CHARLES PHILIP410CA 08-01485(119720)
T.L.C. WEST, LLC, v FASHION OUTLETS OF NIAGARA, LLC,1597CA 08-01222(128572)
 
Oneida
BENNETT, BARBARA v DELIA, ELIS J.477CA 08-01626(CA2006-2308)
BERRY, ARTHUR v UTICA NATIONAL INSURANCE GROUP,476CA 08-01946(CA2007-1405)
CAPOCCETTA, LUIGI, PEOPLE v394KA 08-00680(II07-197)
G., IYONA, MTR. OF474CAF 08-01710(D-02803-07)
GARRETT, WILLIE, PEOPLE v416KA 07-00455(I05-226)
KOZIOL, LEON R. v KOZIOL, KELLY HAWSE1706CA 08-00165(D-42102)
KOZIOL, LEON R. v KOZIOL, KELLY HAWSE1705CA 08-00164(D-42102)
KOZIOL, LEON R. v KOZIOL, KELLY HAWSE1704CA 08-00163(D-42102)
KOZIOL, LEON R. v KOZIOL, KELLY HAWSE1703CA 07-02530(D-42102)
P., AMONI, MTR. OF491CAF 07-01826(NN-00616-07, NN-00617-07
ROACHE, WALTER J. v CONNELL, S.A.333KAH 08-00685(CA2004-749)
SULLIVAN CONTRACTING, INC., v TURNER CONSTRUCTION CO.,162CA 08-01729(CA 2005 - 2489)
 
Onondaga
BALL, LARRY v CITY OF SYRACUSE,154CA 08-00707(07-7610)
BISHOP, ANDREW E., PEOPLE v397KA 08-00657(I2008-69-1)
COBAUGH, SUSAN M., PEOPLE v263KA 04-01490(I2004-0348-2)
COMFORT, JAMES E., PEOPLE v81KA 05-00820(I2003-0325-1)
COMFORT, JAMES, PEOPLE v76KA 03-02311(I2003-0325-1)
GUIFFRIDA, MICHAEL v STORICO DEVELOPMENT, LLC,46CA 08-01310(05-3142)
HALLSTON MANOR FARM, LLC, v ANDREW, JULIE LYNN203CA 08-01090(2007-1740)
HOTALING, MICHAEL v EXCELLUS HEALTH PLAN, INC.,340CA 08-01445(2005-0596)
LEONARD, MARY E. v THOMPSON & JOHNSON EQUIPMENT CO.,, INC.93CA 08-01609(2005-3163)
LEONARD, MARY E. v THOMPSON & JOHNSON EQUIPMENT CO.,, INC.94CA 08-01610(2005-3163)
LEONARD, MARY E. v THOMPSON & JOHNSON EQUIPMENT CO.,, INC.92CA 07-01802(I2005-3163)
LUCIANO, JUAN CARLOS, PEOPLE v192KA 06-03438(I2005-0993-2-V)
MCCURTY, AARON, PEOPLE v486KA 06-01927(I2004-0730-2)
MCCURTY, AARON, PEOPLE v485KA 06-01926(I2005-0013-1)
MILEA, THERESA v CITY OF SYRACUSE,404CA 08-00663(99-1111)
MILEA, THERESA v CITY OF SYRACUSE,403CA 08-00662(99-1111)
OUTLEY, JOANNE v UPSTATE MEDICAL UNIVERSITY,450CA 08-01452(2006-7881)
PETTY, MICHAEL D., PEOPLE v265KA 07-00264(I2005-1369-1)
SWAN, GEORGE, PEOPLE v440KA 07-02334(I2005-1144-1)
TAG MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, INC., v P.S. GRISWOLD CO., INC.,339CA 08-00927(2002-1821)
THOMAS, RONALD, PEOPLE v235KA 06-01214(I2005-0419-1)
WILLIAMS, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v371KA 06-00555(I2005-0518-1)
YOUNIS, DAVID A. v MARTIN, NORMAN J.356CA 08-02071(2007-8151)
 
Ontario
ARMITAGE, PETER A., PEOPLE v465KA 08-01047(I05-DI-036)
BECKER, SEAN, PEOPLE v327KA 06-01606(S06-DI-070)
BELANGER, MICHAEL PAUL, PEOPLE v445KA 08-00337(I07-SORA-004)
COLLIER, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v304KA 07-02421(I07-01-031)
JACOBSON, RYAN W., PEOPLE v190KA 06-02985(I06-01-020)
MCKOY, LAMON, PEOPLE v368KA 05-00425(I04-04-065)
RANDLEMAN, TROY F., PEOPLE v288KA 07-01928(S06-DI-196)
SCHIPPER, JOSHUA D., PEOPLE v373KA 06-01602(I05-07-073)
SCHROM, WALLACE R., PEOPLE v378KA 08-00375(I06-10-135)
VIEIRA, LIONEL T. v HUFF, DIANE P.470CAF 08-00309(V-02718-02/07K)
 
Orleans
EWING, SR., HAROLD E. v BRUNNER INTERNATIONAL, INC.,179CA 08-01846(30948/05)
PITTS, BERNARD v UNGER, DAVID290KAH 08-00395(07-33920)
SANTORO, JOSEPH M., PEOPLE v464KA 08-00444(S05-S-02)
 
Oswego
CAPPETTA, THOMAS C. v MALDONADO, JASMINE310CAF 08-00760(2006ID000003)
J., III, CHRISTOPHER, MTR. OF471CAF 08-01322(B-619-621-06/07B)
JOHNSON, LAURIE v DELTA INTERNATIONAL MACHINERY CORP.,137CA 08-01176(2002-2185)
MALISZEWSKI, PETER J., PEOPLE v1712KA 08-01555(I06C-33)
 
Seneca
FIRST NAMED PUBLIC OFFICIAL, MTR. OF437KA 08-02070(40718A)
IFILL, RICHARD SUNDAY v FISCHER, BRIAN303TP 08-01201(40955)
ZONA, JOSHUA, PEOPLE v33KA 08-01462(I07-068)
 
Steuben
CANTINERI, MICHAEL v CARRERE, FREDERIC205CA 08-00204(92154)
GIARDINA, TERESA A. v CAMPBELL, TERRY L.334CAF 08-00280(O-2034-07)
 
Wayne
COMPTON, DANIEL P. v FREYN, MAUREEN B.312CAF 08-00770(V0977-05/07B)
MERRILL, ROBERT J., PEOPLE v374KA 07-02431(I07-09)
SHORT, KATHLEEN B. v SHORT, RONALD A.140CA 08-01125(00856)
 
Wyoming
CONTI, DANIEL M. v WYOMING COUNTY,433CA 08-01008(39260)
HIZBULLAHANKHAMON, QABAIL v FISCHER, BRIAN229TP 08-01532(20602-08)
MARKOWITZ, ELLIOT v STATE OF NEW YORK,277CA 07-01977(105735)
MCILROY, JAMES v MUSKOKA TRANSPORT, LTD.,381CA 08-00304(35205/2004)
 
Yates
KLEM, JOHN, PEOPLE v379KA 08-01045(S06-69)
PETERSEN, ROBERT, PEOPLE v330KA 08-00482(S07-33)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS