AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - November 13, 2009

 
Cattaraugus
COVELL, ALBERT J., PEOPLE v1274KA 09-00993(S08-088)
 
Cayuga
BAKER, EMMETT, PEOPLE v1422KA 08-01681(I2007-115)
JOHNSON, VARSEY v GRAHAM, HAROLD1434KAH 08-02636(2008-1120)
KAZMIRSKI, JOHN E. v VILLAGE OF WEEDSPORT,1377TP 09-00975(2008-1311)
ROSS, LARRY v GRAHAM, HAROLD1324KAH 08-01265(2007-1329)
WILLIAMS, EDMUND v CORCORAN, MICHAEL P.1410KAH 08-02375(2008-0643)
 
Chautauqua
CARTER, MARLO J., PEOPLE v1342KA 08-02006(I07-578)
DELANEY, JANUARY M., PEOPLE v1402KA 08-00539(I06-476)
DELANEY, JANUARY M., PEOPLE v1403KA 09-01006(S07-051)
M., LORELEI, MTR. OF1280CAF 08-01076(N-2378-2379-06)
 
Erie
ALMODOVAR, RAYMOND v BERBARY, JAMES L.1362KAH 08-01538(I-2008-3153)
BAKER, KEVIN, PEOPLE v1378KA 08-00883(I2007-2458)
CACV OF COLORADO, LLC, MTR. OF1369CA 09-01039(1347/08)
COTTON, MAURICE, PEOPLE v1430KA 08-00369(I2006-1476A)
D., WENDY v G., DEAN1292CA 09-00340(2005-3565)
DALTON, JACQUELINE A. v MEMMINGER, JR., MARTIN K.1182CA 09-00457(I2007-12038)
DAVIS, ALTON, PEOPLE v1322KA 07-02484(I2007-0121)
FERRUCCI, HAROLD A., PEOPLE v1340KA 08-02003(I00414-2008)
GERSTER SALES & SERVICE, INC., v POWER AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF NEW,1291CA 09-01011(12358/2008)
GORDON, KENNETH v PRESBYTERY OF WESTERN NEW YORK,1438CA 09-00787(2008-006996)
GORSKI, PATRICIA v REID, ALLAN T.1171CA 09-00060(I2007/11436)
GORSKI, PATRICIA v REID, ALLAN T.1172CA 09-00061(I2007/11436)
GRINER, JEFFREY M. v FRANKEL, MARLENE MORGAN1306CA 09-00144(I2005-3606)
GUTHRIE, CURT v BERBARY, JAMES L.1334CA 08-01914(I2008-4344)
HART, KEON, PEOPLE v1230KA 08-01375(I2007-2191)
HARZYNSKI, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1405KA 08-01796(I2007-0519)
HARZYNSKI, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1406KA 08-01678(S29940)
HECKL, ROSANNA E. v C., AIDA1240CA 09-00455(SF 2006-902242)
HOLLEY, DOMINIQUE, PEOPLE v1407KA 08-01687(I2007-0817)
HUFFMAN, MARY v DOYLE, DAVID1439CA 09-01092(I2007 - 7732)
HYATT, TERESA v MESSANA, ANTHONY G.1327CA 09-00837(I2007-12536)
JACOBI, JOSEPH v FISH, BRIAN K.1268CA 09-01029(2006-8391)
JANICKI, BARBARA v THOMAS, JR., M.D., REXFORD L.1288CA 09-00797(2005-2955)
JOHNSON, WILLIAM v UNIFIRST CORPORATION,1414CA 09-01087(2007-9424)
JORDAN, CURTIS J., PEOPLE v1344KA 08-02106(S28934)
MAYNARD, FLOYD M., PEOPLE v1304KA 08-01632(I2007-2212)
MCGRIGG, ALFRED K., PEOPLE v1381KA 08-01733(I2005-APP-050)
MENDOLA, ISABELLA v ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER CORPORAT,1418CA 09-01055(2005-8482)
MOLL, BRADLEY v BRANDWOOD, LLC,1245CA 09-00368(I2005-6948)
MORGAN, GLEN v JACOBS, DAVID1242CA 09-00730(2006-8768)
MORRIS, DALE J. v STATE OF NEW YORK,1265CA 08-02292(Claim No. 106569)
NIAGARA FRONTIER TRANSPORTATIONAUTHORITY, MTR. OF1372CA 09-00261(I2008-1605)
NIAGARA FRONTIER TRANSPORTATIONAUTHORITY, MTR. OF1371CA 09-00260(I2008-1605)
O'DONNELL, JAMES v BUFFALO-DS ASSOCIATES, LLC,1367CA 09-00332(2005-568)
PINO ALTO PARTNERS, v ERIE COUNTY WATER AUTHORITY,1263CA 09-01014(I2006-11957)
ROGERS, NICHOLAS, PEOPLE v1318KA 08-01550(S29914)
S., JR., SHAD, MTR. OF1238CAF 08-00175(B-3114-05)
SCHWARTZ, JENNIFER v VUKSON, WAYNE D.1325CA 09-00563(2007-931)
SCOTT, SR., KEITH H. v CITY OF BUFFALO,1309CA 09-00953(2006-1189)
SCULLY, DANIEL J. v HAAR, CAROL M.1125CA 09-00494(SF-2008-901119)
SMITH, LARRY, PEOPLE v1305KA 09-00912(00508-2008)
SWEET, HOWARD A. v TEXACO, INC.,993CA 08-02671(I2005/4459)
TELLO, CAROL, PEOPLE v1338KA 08-00479(S29218)
THE BUFFALO TEACHERS FEDERATION, MTR. OF1328CA 09-01105(12007-11996)
WILKOWSKI, SHEILA v BIG LOTS STORES, INC.,1353CA 08-01233(I2006-8513)
WILSON, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v1319KA 08-01673(I2007-0062)
 
Genesee
EDWARDS, JR., KENNETH L., PEOPLE v1316KA 09-00178(S07-69)
R., KAYLA, MTR. OF1363CAF 08-02262(A-00220-08)
RASMUSSEN, JR., ROBERT J., PEOPLE v1299KA 09-00007(I3989)
WEE, JOHN CHONG-HWAN v UNITED MEMORIAL MEDICAL CENTER,1243CA 08-02299(56192)
 
Herkimer
NICKELL, RHONDA L., PEOPLE v1314KA 07-02093(I05-068-A)
 
Jefferson
WESCOTT, DESIRAE v HANSELL, DAVID A.1400TP 09-01052(2007-877)
 
Livingston
BIANCO, DYLAN M., PEOPLE v1360KA 09-00468(I2008-220)
SHIRE, IVORY v BEZIO, NORMAN B.1252TP 09-00792(2019-2008)
SNYDER, JEFFREY C., PEOPLE v1448KA 08-02128(I99-067)
 
Monroe
A., ASA, MTR. OF1260CAF 08-02343(D-5893-08)
BEITER, GARY v BEITER, MARY ANNE1356CA 08-00993(94-6619)
BEITER, GARY v BEITER, MARY ANNE1357CA 09-01094(94-6619)
BENTON, ASTIN, PEOPLE v1234KA 07-01130(S07/3205)
BROWN, DARIUS, PEOPLE v1408KA 06-02823(I140/06)
BROWN, JERMAINE, PEOPLE v1382KA 05-01911(I722/04)
BROWN, JERMAINE M., PEOPLE v1383KA 06-00458(I2004-0722)
CARELOCK, ROBERT, PEOPLE v1359KA 05-02286(I05-203)
COOLING TOWER SPECIALTIES, INC., v YARO ENTERPRISES, INC.,1419CA 09-01020(2007/16940)
DOODY, KATHLEEN v GOTTSHALL, KENNETH L.1177CA 08-01871(06-3983)
DOODY, KATHLEEN v GOTTSHALL, KENNETH L.1178CA 08-01872(06-3983)
DUMBLETON, RANDY J., PEOPLE v1431KA 07-00442(I2006-0038)
GARCIA-GUAL, OSCAR E., PEOPLE v1231KA 06-02482(844/2005)
GAYDEN, JOHN, PEOPLE v1303KA 06-02480(I906/2005)
HARRINGTON, MICHAEL A., PEOPLE v1429KA 07-00547(I2006-0412)
HENRIETTA PIPING, INC., v ANTETOMASO & MICCA GROUP, LLC,1264CA 09-00411(12042-05)
JAMES, WILLIE, PEOPLE v1361KA 05-01750(I704/04)
JOHNSON, GRADY L., PEOPLE v1232KA 07-01972(I2005-0196)
KINARD, RICHARD, PEOPLE v1071KA 06-01298(I2005-0625)
KRAFT, LAURA, PEOPLE v1301KA 06-03042(I809/05)
LEWIS, JAMELL, PEOPLE v1321KA 06-00554(I2005/0229)
LVI ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, INC., MTR. OF1464CA 09-01454(2009-8251)
MANGES, DANIEL, PEOPLE v1054KA 06-02131(I2005-0686)
MCGRATH, KAREN v TOWN OF IRONDEQUOIT,1462CA 08-02622(2005-13180)
NOCO ENERGY CORP., v STATE OF NEW YORK,1222CA 08-00587(103873)
PARKER, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1343KA 07-00536(I2006-0058)
PEREZ, OSCAR v GRECIAN GARDEN APARTMENTS, LLC,1349CA 09-00976(2004/11435)
PONDER, ALEXANDER, PEOPLE v1277KA 06-00413(I2005-624)
SMITH, RANSOM Z., PEOPLE v1341KA 07-02034(I2004-0703)
ST. ANN'S HOME FOR THE AGED, v DAINES, M.D., RICHARD F.1040CA 09-00219(07/14187)
T., SAMANTHA, MTR. OF1228CAF 09-00917(S 5885-08/08A)
THE RIDGE ROAD FIRE DISTRICT, v NOWAK, KEVIN1153CA 09-00652(2006/2089)
ZUHLKE, DONOVAN, PEOPLE v1144KA 06-00965(I387/05)
 
Niagara
ALLEN, KELLI M., PEOPLE v1339KA 08-01988(I2007-491)
BURTON, IRIC v PORTER, ADRIENNE Y.1443CA 09-00220(132645)
BUTLER, LYNDA L., PEOPLE v1259KA 08-00012(I2005-025-4V)
BUTLER, LYNDA, PEOPLE v1254KA 08-01037(I2005-602)
CRUZ, DARAIN, PEOPLE v1276KA 08-02537(I2008-221)
DILLON, RAOUL, PEOPLE v1278KA 08-02530(I2003-322-2)
PARLATO, JR., FRANK v INCREDIBLE INVESTMENTS LIMITED,1269CA 08-01817(130869)
PARLATO, JR., FRANK v INCREDIBLE INVESTMENTS LIMITED,1270CA 08-01818(130869)
PARLATO, JR., FRANK v INCREDIBLE INVESTMENTS LIMITED,1271CA 08-01819(130869)
REITZ, LYNN, MTR. OF1351CA 08-02670
THOMAS JOHNSON, INC., v THE STATE INSURANCE FUND,1241CA 09-00587(125316/06)
W., ELSWORTH L. v D., PAMELA1239CAF 08-01101(P-01330-07)
 
Oneida
BROWN, DELAMAR, PEOPLE v1255KA 07-01183(I04-453)
BURTON, CARLTON v CONNELL, SUSAN1297TP 09-00916(ca2008-003645)
C., JR., ROBERTO, MTR. OF1283CAF 09-00125(B-02047-08)
CAPOCCETTA, GIOVANNI, PEOPLE v1317KA 08-01007(II07-197)
HUEN NEW YORK, INC., v BOARD OF EDUCATION CLINTON CENTRAL,1127CA 09-00421(CA2005-001680)
KALWARA, STANLEY E. v LAMANNA, SAMUEL L.1326CA 08-02282(CA2007-513A)
KIERSZNOWSKI, JOAN v SHANKMAN, M.D., P.C., GREGORY B.1247CA 08-02617(2006-000645)
KILGORE, NANCY v SCOTT, BEVERLY1289CA 08-01958(1052/2005)
KILGORE, NANCY v SCOTT, BEVERLY1290CA 08-02621(2005-1052)
MARRIOTT, GAIL, MTR. OF1370CA 08-01573(2007-249)
MIMASSI, MICHAEL J., MTR. OF1444.1CA 09-01199(CA2008-003799)
MURAWSKI, JEFFREY D., PEOPLE v1337KA 08-02255(II07-397)
P., ANDREW, MTR. OF1412CAF 07-02385(NA-05357-06, NN-05358-06
ROTHDIENER, THOMAS E. v STATE OF NEW YORK RACING,1366CA 09-01017(CA2008-002629)
SHORT, RONNIE v FISCHER, BRIAN S.1295TP 09-00784(CA2008-3453)
SIERSON, BRIAN E. v GACEK, JOHN J.1392CA 09-01091(CA2005-002540)
THAYER, RODNEY J. v THAYER, ROSEMARY1237CAF 08-01195(V-04570-07, V-04571-07)
WESSELDINE, DARRELL v COUNTY OF ONEIDA,1266CA 09-00795(2005-002447)
YADDOW, JR., WAYNE E. v BIANCO, LISA M.1388CAF 08-02393(V-05564-07/08 B, C, D)
 
Onondaga
BACKUS, CODY, PEOPLE v1384KA 08-00519(I2007-0474-1)
BELL, THOMAS M. v RAYMOND, MARIE CARROL1348CAF 08-01570(V-00964-06/08C)
DESTINY USA HOLDINGS, LLC, v CITIGROUP GLOBAL MARKETS REALTY, CORP.1136.2CA 09-01520(2009-4157)
G., STEVEN, MTR. OF1386CAF 08-01920(B-4856-07)
HARRIS, MARK S. v HUEBER-BREUER CONSTRUCTION CO., INC,1199CA 09-00456(2005-6644)
JAMES, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v1235KA 08-00839(I2003-0631-22)
JONES, CHRISTOPHER v HILL'S HEATING & AIR CONDITIONING,1395CA 09-01086(2006-6079)
K., AMANDA M., MTR. OF1282CAF 08-01695(NN-3791-07/07A)
KIMBROUGH, EUGENE, PEOPLE v1140KA 06-01297(I2005-0288-1)
MANNING, TYRELL L., PEOPLE v1272KA 05-01417(I2004-0894)
MASSEY, JUSTIN M. v MONETTE, JOHN D.1417CA 09-00642(2005-4523)
MONDELLO, SR., SALVATORE v FARRELL, THOMAS1352CA 09-00570(2003-5337)
NIELSEN, TAMMY, PEOPLE v1409KA 09-00162(I2007-1198-1)
ONEIDA INDIAN NATION, v HUNT CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC.,1156CA 09-00354(2008-5453)
PALISADES COLLECTION, LLC, v KEDIK, BARBARA1065CA 08-02623(2007-8144)
RIVERS, CHARLES L., PEOPLE v1401KA 07-02521(I2007-0618-1)
S., FRANCIS, MTR. OF1413CAF 07-02690(NN-2273-2275-07/07A)
WILEY, NICHOLAS, PEOPLE v1258KA 05-02127(I2005-0215-1)
WILLIAMS, NATHANIEL, PEOPLE v1379KA 06-03659(I06-1021-1)
 
Ontario
JONES, ANTHONY M., PEOPLE v1404KA 08-01019(I07-04-061)
MARCH, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v1315KA 08-00629(I07-04-67)
RIVERA, HAROLD J., PEOPLE v1427KA 08-01753(I07-07-083)
SINGLETON, WILLIE, PEOPLE v1447KA 07-02356(I07-01-018)
WICKSALL, SUZANNE B., PEOPLE v1273KA 07-01444(I06-01-023)
 
Oswego
BROWN, DONALD F., PEOPLE v1233KA 07-00893(I06C-0017)
STRAUTS, ALEXANDER E., PEOPLE v1275KA 08-02091(I03C-188-V)
WALKER, MYRNA v WALKER, III, ROBERT F.1262CA 08-02448(2002-2277)
 
Seneca
MALDONADO, FRANKIE v WILLIAMS, MELVIN1044KAH 09-00171(40988)
PEREZ, JOSE R., PEOPLE v1024KA 08-01122(I07-064)
 
Steuben
ABEEL, CHRISTOPHER E., PEOPLE v1346KA 09-00968(2008-186) & (1002276)
DINEEN, ROBERT v RECHICHI, DANIEL1267CA 09-00764(94290)
DREWERY, DAMIAN, PEOPLE v1320KA 08-02138(I2007-368)
ROSE, DANIEL D., PEOPLE v1428KA 09-00750(97176)
 
Wayne
BASS DEVELOPMENT OF NEW YORK, INC., v BAISCH, NEIL D.1308CA 09-00397(59218)
EBRAHIM, MURTADA, PEOPLE v1298KA 08-02280(S08-W21)
JACOBS, MICHAEL v CHADWICK, KATHLEEN1261CAF 08-01357(V-00848-07,)
 
Wyoming
DRAWHORN, RICKIE v FISCHER, BRIAN1251TP 09-00911(20731-08)
FRIAS, FRANKLYN v FISCHER, BRIAN1253TP 09-00908(20760-08)
KALWASINSKI, MITCHELL v FISCHER, BRIAN1396CA 08-00575(20,511-07)
SANTANA, MICHAEL v FISCHER, BRIAN1250TP 09-00909(20741-08)
VIGLIOTTI, JACK v FISCHER, BRIAN1294TP 09-00910(20733-08)
 
Yates
YOUNGS, STEVEN L., PEOPLE v1323KA 09-01003(92-31)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS