AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - February 11, 2010

 
Allegany
HEVERLY, MARCIA L. v NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF CHILDREN,13TP 09-01878(36799)
MORGAN, H. WAYNE, PEOPLE v92KA 09-01845(06-054)
WESOLOWSKI, JAMES, PEOPLE v6KA 09-01559(05-086-42)
 
Cattaraugus
DRAKE, MILFORD C. v FOX, DALE F.37CA 09-01720(69763)
T., JORGE N., PEOPLE v1566KA 08-00215(I07-051-01)
WARRIOR, NORMA v BEATMAN, SR., ROBERT95CAF 09-00005(V-03208-02/07R)
 
Cayuga
HARRIS, FRANK v GRAHAM, HAROLD205KAH 08-01031(2007-1429)
MCDANIELS, ANDREW v CORCORAN, MICHAEL94KAH 08-02009(2008-0325)
MORRIS, JERMAINE L., PEOPLE v87KA 09-00170(S2008-137)
SHORT, CHARLES M. v PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INSURANCE,1695CA 09-00072(08-533)
WILLIAMS, JERMAINE L., PEOPLE v200KA 08-02386(S2008-067)
 
Chautauqua
CARTER, LAWRENCE v WARD, JR., JOHN TAYLOR240OP 09-02584(09-0015)
G., DYLAN, MTR. OF183CAF 09-01558(D-324-08)
K., SEAN P., MTR. OF12CAF 09-00881(D-325-08)
SCHMIDT, JASON L. v LORENZO, GREGORY V.104CA 09-01098(K1-2008-90)
SCHMIDT, JASON L. v LORENZO, GREGORY V.105CA 09-01099(K1-2008-90)
SCHMIDT, JASON L. v LORENZO, GREGORY V.106CA 09-01100(K1-2008-90)
SEXTON, DOROTHY L. v RESINGER, WILDA KIMBALL100CA 09-01546(K1-2007-392)
 
Erie
ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY, v LASKER, THOMAS172CA 09-01918(011839/2008)
ANDERSON, RACHEL v WEINBERG, NEIL1478CA 09-01238(I 2006 000062)
ANDREOZZI, MARY LOU v TOPS MARKETS, LLC,170CA 09-01702(I2006-9409)
BOLDEN, JOHN, PEOPLE v86KA 08-01466(I2007-1104)
BROWN, JAZZMONE, PEOPLE v7KA 08-01039(I2002-2148)
BUNCH, TONETTE DENISE v WEBSTER, ZRINELL JOHN53CAF 09-00477(F-21803-99/08B)
BURNS, ROBIN v BURNS, THOMAS E.1680CA 09-00959(SF902141/2006)
BURNS, STEVEN, PEOPLE v5KA 07-02241(I2005-1622)
BURNS, STEVEN, PEOPLE v4KA 07-02240(I2005-1380)
CARR, JR., CLARENCE, PEOPLE v1609KA 08-01145(I2006-1872)
CARROW, ROGER v BOGARD, STEPHEN1618CA 08-02178(2006-8484)
CHILES, CLEVELAND, PEOPLE v1561KA 08-02139(S00700-2008)
COLLINS, GREGORY, PEOPLE v112KA 09-01847(00631-2004)
COMERFORD, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v8KA 09-00941(I00736-2007)
CONIGLIO, ANTHONY M. v THE ANDERSONS, INC.,168CA 09-01007(I-2003-465/645TP)
COVANTA NIAGARA, L.P., v TOWN OF AMHERST,1483CA 09-01352(2008/3701)
CROUCH, JACKIE, PEOPLE v116KA 08-01773(I2007-1558)
CWIKLINSKI, PAUL v SEARS, ROEBUCK & CO., INC.,1621CA 09-01435(4000/92)
DAVIS, KENNETH v WIND-SUN CONSTRUCTION, INC.,150CA 09-01001(I-2007-11344)
DELPRINCE, JONAS, PEOPLE v84KA 08-01560(I2007-0833)
DULAK, THOMAS, PEOPLE v108KA 08-02599(S29347)
ESTATE OF EUGENE JASON, v HERDMAN, LISA147CA 09-01643(08-11148)
FARREN, PHILIP M., PEOPLE v130KA 08-01896(S29949)
FARREN, PHILIP M., PEOPLE v129KA 08-01895(I01492-2007)
GROCHOWSKI, LISA M. v FUDELLA, JASON P.210CA 09-01826(2005-10415)
GRUBEA, CHRISTINE A. v GRUBEA, PETER D.1576CA 09-00868(SF2003-902450)
HEADLEY, DONNA v M&J LIMITED PARTNERSHIP,17CA 09-01706(I2006-4060)
HELPING HANDS OF WESTERN NEW YORK, v CARRION, GLADYS1624TP 09-01031(2009-3295)
HILL, GREGORY, PEOPLE v1667KA 08-01267(I2007-0036)
HIMMELSBACH, DEBORAH v GEORGE, PATRICK1573CA 09-01144(I2007-011730)
HOPKINS, JR., JAMES R. v GELIA, GINA F.54CAF 08-02258(F-13157-05/08A)
HUBEL, JAMES, PEOPLE v1670KA 08-02640(I0756-2002A)
IGNATOWSKI, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v1610KA 08-02672(S28074)
KEMP, MARLIN, PEOPLE v3KA 08-00856(I2007-3047)
KUSTES, KOREY P. v CUMMINGS, NICOLE S.236CA 09-01928(I-2007-7064)
LEHIGH CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC., v LEXINGTON INSURANCE COMPANY,1390CA 09-01066(I 2008-04586)
MAURER, NICOLE S. v KISER, RAYMOND E.1681.4CA 08-02330(I2003-10083)
MAURER, NICOLE S. v TOPS MARKETS, LLC,1681.3CA 08-02271(2002-10095)
MAURER, NICOLE S. v KISER, RAYMOND E.1681.2CA 08-02321(I2003-1008)
MAURER, NICOLE S. v TOPS MARKETS, LLC,1681.1CA 08-02270(I2002-10095)
MITCHELL, PAMELA v ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER CORP.,211CA 09-01836(2008-4671)
N&W CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC., v ROOSA FAMILY ASSOCIATES,121CA 09-01724(2006-4598)
NORTHWAY, CAROLE A. v NORTHWAY, SR., C. GREG77CA 09-00961(SF2006/900654)
QUIGLEY, ALLAN, PEOPLE v219KA 08-00853(I0082-2007)
QUIGLEY, ALLAN, PEOPLE v220KA 08-00855(I2007-0082)
RACZKA, STEVEN v RAMIREZ, DAVID F.1623CA 09-00107(I2003-7764)
REYNHOUT, JONATHAN C. v HUESTON, DEBORAH213CA 09-01722(2008-391319)
RICHARDSON, JR., CARL J., PEOPLE v43KA 08-02233(I2007-2058)
SMALLS, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v44KA 08-01040(I2006-2916)
STRAW, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v65KA 08-02484(S28511)
SZYMKOWIAK, NANCY v DORITEX CORP.,120CA 09-01911(2007-11516)
THOMPSON, TARSHAWN, PEOPLE v29KA 08-02247(I2007-0256)
TORRES-REYES, ERNESTO, PEOPLE v70KA 08-02119(S29909)
VANBUSKIRK, SCOTT v STATE OF NEW YORK,18CA 09-01909(107578)
VELLON, FELIX, PEOPLE v155KA 08-01271(I2004-0196-001)
 
Genesee
AQUINO, THOMAS, PEOPLE v2KA 08-01885(S08-26)
BRUSIE, DAVID, PEOPLE v181KA 08-02133(S07-054)
BURNS, KENNETH v CITY OF BATAVIA,19CA 09-00671(53093)
BURNS, KENNETH v CITY OF BATAVIA,20CA 09-00672(53093)
OLIVER, EVELYN D. v OLIVER, BENJAMIN F.1285CA 08-00464(53096)
STEVENSON, BRUCE L. v STEVENSON, DEBORAH K.1699CAF 09-01175(V-0005-97/08F & G)
 
Herkimer
PACE, CHARLES, PEOPLE v111KA 08-02207(I07-035)
SPORTELLO, LORIE v SPORTELLO, MICHAEL A.1524CAF 08-02431(V-01637-07/07A,)
SPORTELLO, LORIE v SPORTELLO, MICHAEL A.1526CAF 08-02433(V-01637-07/08G)
SPORTELLO, LORIE v SPORTELLO, MICHAEL A.1525CAF 08-02432(V-01637-07/08C)
STEWART, WAYNE, PEOPLE v113KA 09-01792(06-43)
WELLINGTON, JEAN, MTR. OF1690CAF 08-02488(V-00232-08/08A)
 
Jefferson
CLOE, RANDY v THE ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR THE STATE, NEW YORK78CA 09-01407(08-0481)
GIGUERE, CLAUDE v BARKLEY, WARREN31KAH 09-00304(08-3214)
JORDAN, RUBY v PREMO, RICHARD1579CA 08-02420(95-1704)
RIVERA, CARLOS L., PEOPLE v1629KA 08-02137(I08-708-07)
 
Lewis
NUFFER, ROYAL, PEOPLE v1KA 09-01775(2008-061)
PIERCE, MICHAEL D., PEOPLE v23KA 08-02466(I2005-135)
 
Livingston
ANZALONE, DANIEL, PEOPLE v1664KA 09-01432(2007-078)
GRAHAM, FRANK v FISCHER, BRIAN141KAH 08-01977(762-2008)
MCMILLON, JR., ANDRE M., PEOPLE v28KA 08-00881(I2007-146)
 
Monroe
C., NICO S., MTR. OF1614CAF 09-01291(D-8737-08)
CHOMIK, CATHERINE v SYPNIAK, JAROSLAW55CAF 09-00701(F-3238-01/08C,D)
COAN, MARY LOUISE v THOMPSON, THOMAS N.1284CAF 08-01934(F-12998-03)
CONWAY BEAM LEASING, INC., v SHERMAR, INC.,56CA 09-00187(2005/00510)
CORGAN, STEPHEN J. v THE DIMARCO GROUP, LLC,218CA 09-00964(07/02407)
CORGAN, STEPHEN v THE DIMARCO GROUP, LLC,215CA 09-00842(07/02407)
CORGAN, STEPHEN J. v THE DIMARCO GROUP, LLC,217CA 09-00963(07/02407)
CORGAN, STEPHEN v THE DIMARCO GROUP, LLC,216CA 09-00962(07/02407)
COSME, JORGE L., PEOPLE v110KA 07-00258(I2006-0240B)
DARRISAW, TIMOTHY C., PEOPLE v160KA 05-00437(I04-0685)
DUVALL, SHAWNDELL J., PEOPLE v85KA 05-01424(I2003-0620)
ENGLERT, LEONARD M. v SCHAFFER, JR., ESQ., GERALD W.22CA 09-01598(2006/12365)
FALCO, VINCENT v ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY,1567CA 09-01436(08-1731)
GIGNAC, R.PH, DANA RENE v PATERSON, DAVID15TP 09-01616(2009-5451)
GOLLOGLY, SHANE PATRICK v THOMPSON, HILARY L.118CAF 09-00486(V-6831-05)
GUZMAN, RAYMOND, PEOPLE v46KA 06-03045(I950/05)
HARVEY, QUINTON T., PEOPLE v1563KA 07-02330(I2007-0166A)
HAYWOOD, LAMONT v HARRIS, AUDREY50CAF 08-01781(V0004679-05/08E)
HEIL, DAVID, PEOPLE v1669KA 09-01057(I2006-0862)
HUNTER, SHAWN, PEOPLE v74KA 06-03433(I2005-0800)
JEFFERY, THOMAS, PEOPLE v1687KA 08-01836(I2007-0279)
KITTS, SUSAN B. v BLOSSOM NORTH, LLC,63CA 09-00906(2008/2268)
KITTS, SUSAN B. v BLOSSOM NORTH, LLC,62CA 09-00905(2008/2268)
LARSEN, KIMBERLY M. v BANWAR, M.D., NITIN S.57CA 09-01040(2005-711)
MANCUSO, PATRICIA v ALLERGY ASSOCIATES OF ROCHESTER,1678CA 09-00038(06-4762)
MARTINEZ, JOHN K. v TAMBE ELECTRIC, INC.,125CA 09-01331(3746-05)
MASON, JAMAL D., PEOPLE v93KA 05-01323(I2003-0559D)
MATEO, LUIS A., PEOPLE v45KA 05-01870(I2004-0550)
MOALIM, KADIJA v HENEHAN, ELIZABETH C.235CA 09-00535(2044/7737)
PELUSIO FAMILY PARTNERSHIP, L.P., v MASSACHUSETTS MUTAL LIFE INSURANCE,97CA 09-01896(07-11937)
PLUMMER, RICHARD F. v PLUMMER, JENNIFER M.166CAF 08-01528(V-00871-08)
POLES, DEGLOYDE, PEOPLE v199KA 06-03648(I2005-0833)
RIDDICK, MALCOLM T., PEOPLE v1257KA 06-03426(I004/06)
ROBLES, RICHARD v ALEXANDER, GEORGE B.58CA 09-00786(15115/08)
ROGERS, CARL L., PEOPLE v64KA 05-01909(I29/05)
RUTLEDGE, ANTONIO D., PEOPLE v114KA 08-02140(I2007-0514)
S., VERONICA v S., PHILIP R.1572CA 08-01848(2006/6848)
SHORT, KRISTINE E. v DALOIA, GERALD152CA 09-01426(06-13367)
SHORT, KRISTINE E. v DALOIA, GERALD153CA 09-01427(06-13367)
VALLE, JOSE ALPHONSO, PEOPLE v156KA 07-00950(I733/05)
VARGAS, THERESA M., PEOPLE v9KA 07-01573(I2005-0843)
WARNEY, DOUGLAS v STATE OF NEW YORK,1615CA 08-02261(114826)
WEST, BRANDON, PEOPLE v1683KA 07-02561(I2007-0301)
WHITE, QUINNTARIUS, PEOPLE v72KA 04-01394(I03-489)
ZHANG, YU v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN,229TP 09-01846(2009-4789)
 
Niagara
CITY OF LOCKPORT, DELUCAS, KELLY v149CA 09-01910(129309)
CRUMPLER, LAMON C., PEOPLE v182KA 09-00575(I2007-587)
FAERY, LELAND J. v CITY OF LOCKPORT,124CA 09-01883(126792)
LARATONDA, CARMEN v LEWISTON-PORTER CENTRAL SCHOOL DIST,234CA 09-01912(134857)
MERCO, INC., v NIAGARA FALLS WATER BOARD,239CA 09-02472(139011)
 
Oneida
ALEXANDER, CYNTHIA JOY v PALAKA, III, JOSEPH J.186CAF 08-01533(V-02529-04/08 B,C,D,E)
ANNUCCI, ANTHONY, WILLIAMS, RAY v75KAH 09-01349(CA2008-002617)
B., TIARA, MTR. OF10CAF 08-01211(B-01439-07)
CAMACHO, YESHUA, PEOPLE v179KA 08-00349(II07-161)
CONNOLLY, DAVID C., PEOPLE v1685KA 08-00915(II07-269)
F., TRAYVAUGHN, MTR. OF184CAF 09-00656(B-05165-08)
FELIZ, JOSE A., PEOPLE v91KA 08-00397(I07-088)
FULLER, FREDDY H., PEOPLE v174KA 07-01036(II05-309)
HYMES, JAMES C., PEOPLE v117KA 05-01420(II04-479)
IKEDA, PATRICIA v TEDESCO, DANIELLE M.1676CA 09-01318(CA2007-001248)
LEARNED, SHARON H. v FAXTON-ST. LUKE'S HEALTHCARE,187CA 09-01620(CA2005-001401)
LEWIS, STEFANY V. v LEWIS, JOHN F.1391CA 08-01424(D2006-042540)
MAXFIELD, NICOLE K., PEOPLE v131KA 08-02641(II08-135)
ROSADO, HECTOR R., PEOPLE v25KA 08-00483(II07-088)
SCHILLACI, JOSEPH v FORBES, CHARMAINE1523CAF 08-02589(V-04295-03/08E)
TREGLIA, MICHAEL v COLGATE UNIVERSITY,1700.1CA 09-01814(CA2007-001518)
VELEZ, ANTONIO v MANCE, JAMES A.195TP 09-01734(CA2009-001286)
WELLMAN, JR., ELLIS CLARK v AJELLO, RONALD V.193CA 09-01885(CA2005-001500)
WELLMAN, JR., ELLIS CLARK v AJELLO, RONALD V.194CA 09-01888(CA2005-001500)
 
Onondaga
A., CUNNTREL, MTR. OF11CAF 09-00584(NN-5203-5206-08)
ANDERSON, JR., WILLIAM, PEOPLE v30KA 09-01550(08-0144) & (2008-0172-1)
BALENGER, ERIC, PEOPLE v27KA 06-03477(I2006-0102-1)
BROWN, LA'SHAWN D., PEOPLE v67KA 07-00836(I2006-0068-1)
CRYSTAL RUN NEWCO, LLC, v UNITED PET SUPPLY, INC.,1225CA 09-00612(2007-7510)
FERENCHAK, PAUL v FERENCHAK, KATHRYN40CA 09-00704(2006-M-0832)
FRAZIER, RODNEY, PEOPLE v1682KA 07-00396(I2006-0099-1)
HARTMAN-JWEID, DIANE S. v OVERBAUGH, MATTHEW K.188CA 09-01850(2003-7793)
HUNTER, DAMON, PEOPLE v161KA 06-03780(I2005-0889-1)
IRWIN, JOHN M. v ONONDAGA COUNTY RESOURCE RECOVERY, AGENCY1420CA 09-00303(I2008-4060)
IRWIN, JOHN M. v ONONDAGA COUNTY RESOURCE RECOVERY, AGENCY1421CA 09-00305(I2008-4060)
JAY N JEN, INC., v POLGE SEAFOOD DISTRIBUTING, INC.,1528CA 09-00518(07-2636)
JAY N JEN, INC., v POLGE SEAFOOD DISTRIBUTING, INC.,1529CA 09-00519(07-2636)
JONES, DAVID, PEOPLE v1686KA 07-00451(I2006-0953-1)
LANDERS, JOHN THOMAS v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,39CA 09-01211(I2007-0561)
LEARY, ISAAC, PEOPLE v180KA 08-02509(I2007-0671-1)
MICHAEL, LUKE v STATE OF NEW YORK,80CA 09-01338(111667)
MURPHY, CHARLENE M. v MURPHY, THOMAS R.76CA 09-01564(2006-M-0601)
OWENS, ROBBIE D., PEOPLE v1608KA 08-00914(2006-1336) & (I06-1097-1)
OWENS, ROBBIE D., PEOPLE v1607KA 07-00939(I06-1097-1)
PALLADINO, EUGENE v CNY CENTRO, INC.,1532CA 09-01523(2008-2623)
POLLARD, JAMES R., PEOPLE v201KA 08-01270(I2007-1006-1)
PROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE CO., v HARCO NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY,1675CA 09-00898(2006-4921)
S., CORY, MTR. OF32CAF 08-00087(NA-66-67-07)
TURNER, LIZA A. v VULCAN, STEVE M.191CA 09-00412(2004-2100)
VAUGHN, CHARLES N. v LAMBERT, EARNESTINE33CAF 09-00262(V-10903-04/08A)
WALKER, JR., EDDIE COREY v BOWMAN, TEESHA B.34CAF 08-01246(V-03035-08)
 
Ontario
BUTLER, KEVIN J., PEOPLE v1684KA 07-02658(I06-10-167)
ERB, JR., CARL D., PEOPLE v138KA 08-01770(I07-10-132)
HETELEKIDES, KRYSTALO v COUNTY OF ONTARIO,209CA 09-01784(100932)
HUTSON, PATRICK J. v HUTSON, STACY M.142CAF 09-00636(V-02139/140-08)
LENO-MARCH, APRIL, PEOPLE v24KA 08-00890(I07-04-067)
MCLAUGHLIN, CHARLES R. v MIDROX INSURANCE COMPANY,1577CA 08-01863(97176)
MCLAUGHLIN, CHARLES R. v MIDROX INSURANCE COMPANY,1578CA 08-02196(97176)
N., RACHAEL, MTR. OF119CAF 08-01219(B-00223-07)
ROSADO, PETER, PEOPLE v47KA 08-01264(I03-01-035)
VANDEWATER, KELLY v CANANDAIGUA NATIONAL BANK,1393CA 09-00040(07-3853)
WALKER, ERNESTINE v GOLD, NEIL H.81CA 09-01733(100116)
 
Orleans
CAMPOLITO, ANTHONY v HALE, KEVIN1611KAH 08-02380(08-34894)
GLANTON, ROMARIS v KHAHAIFA, S.71TP 09-01447(09-36284)
MCAVOY, JOSEPH R., PEOPLE v1606KA 07-00520(I06-13)
RADUNS, NICOLE J., PEOPLE v90KA 09-00164(S08-S-21)
WHITE, BENITH, PEOPLE v26KA 08-02542(I07-66)
 
Oswego
BARLOW, SR., KEVIN J., PEOPLE v1668KA 08-00542(I07C-130)
BERGMAN, GARY T., PEOPLE v1671KA 08-01368(I07C-092)
ST. LAURENT, STEPHEN C., PEOPLE v1141KA 08-01980(I07C-47)
THOMPSON, DIANNA v MATHER, JOSEPH EDWARD1437CA 09-00850(06-492)
 
Seneca
GILLON, AUGUST J. v TRAINA, CARL D.1485CA 07-02646(36343)
JACKSON, DALE, PEOPLE v154KA 09-01873(09RISK-01)
O'CONNELL, PETER M. v GRAVES, JAMES B.1535CA 09-00410(39673)
PERALES, RICHARD v LEMPKE, JOHN230KAH 08-02545(41823)
 
Steuben
BROWN, RANDY, PEOPLE v134KA 08-01764(I2006-246)
BROWN, RANDY, PEOPLE v135KA 08-01765(I2007-158)
DOBSON, TREVOR, PEOPLE v221KA 08-02647(S2007-356W)
DOBSON, TREVOR, PEOPLE v222KA 08-02648(S2007-357W)
DRAKE, CHARLES v HOFFMAN, BERTHA1641CA 09-01370(87424)
HEVERLY, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v202KA 08-02000(I2007-133)
HSBC BANK USA, MTR. OF36CA 09-00987(19675)
K., DAKOTA L., MTR. OF51CAF 09-01113(D-00092-09)
MCPHERSON, JOHN, PEOPLE v89KA 08-02122(I2006-193)
MOORE, RONDELLE, PEOPLE v109KA 08-01976(I2007-319)
 
Wayne
COSTANZO, JAMES v MORRISEY, JAMES206KAH 09-00858(08-WRIT-6)
GALLAHER, JAMES v REPUBLIC FRANKLIN INSURANCE COMPANY,99CA 09-00126(59893)
GREEN, ALJUAN, PEOPLE v177KA 08-02219(I08-51)
STREETER, TALMADGE, PEOPLE v196KA 08-02215(S07-W87)
WITHERSPOON, BILLY v MORRISSEY, JAMES1475KAH 08-02538(07-WRIT-11)
 
Wyoming
EGBERT, PHILIP v FISCHER, BRIAN178TP 09-01717(20780-09)
HAWKINS, CHRISTOPHER T., PEOPLE v163KA 07-01882(I5599)
MCMASTER, KENNETH, PEOPLE v223KA 08-01502(I5807)
 
Yates
SMALL BUSINESS LOAN SOURCE, LLC, v KAIVAL KALI CORPORATION,1696CA 09-01264(2006-0470)
    
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS