AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - June 11, 2010

 
Allegany
BOXHORN, LESLIE v ALLIANCE IMAGING, INC.,564CA 09-02581(31996)
 
Cattaraugus
HOMAN, LESTER v COUNTY OF CATTARAUGUS DEPARTMENT,614CA 09-02369(76064)
HORN, LAURA L. v HORN, JEFFREY H.806CAF 09-01170(V-01420-08/08A)
REES, SHAWN, PEOPLE v753KA 09-00583(I05-036)
SECRIST, ROBERT D., PEOPLE v818KA 09-00532(I07-131)
STROUD, ROBERT M. v VAHL, MARY HOLLENDER539CAF 09-02422(F-1020-00)
 
Cayuga
BROWN, CLARENCE R., PEOPLE v599KA 08-02462(I2007-040)
HENRY, KEVIN P., PEOPLE v840KA 08-01497(I2007-038)
SMITH, III, JOHN W., PEOPLE v857KA 09-00824(I2008-118)
TRATT, KIMBERLY A. v COUNTY OF CAYUGA,809CA 09-01667(2007-0712)
 
Chautauqua
THE RESOURCE CENTER, v NYSARC, INC.,610CA 09-02573(K1-2007-95)
 
Erie
AIKEN, LANCE, PEOPLE v708KA 09-00222(I2007-0122)
ALLSAFE TECHNOLOGIES, INC., v BENZ, CHARLES634CA 09-02548(2007-8492)
B., MADDISON, MTR. OF828CAF 09-01562(B-19082-08)
BENEVENTO, RICHARD v CITY OF BUFFALO,572CA 09-02612(I2005-4819)
COOPER, ELIZABETH v COOPER, RICHARD L.866CAF 10-00216(F-03614-08)
D., ELIJAH, MTR. OF805CAF 09-00876(B-15667-2007)
DOHERTY, JENNIFER M. v MERCHANTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,1617CA 09-01495(2005-6135)
DOZIER, DANIEL, PEOPLE v729KA 09-00852(I2008-0664)
DUGAN, JESSICA ANN, PEOPLE v757KA 09-01578(I2008-2598)
FALK, PATRICIA A. v FALK, BRUCE R.791CA 10-00106(SF 2003-902961)
GARZA, ESMERALDA v TARAVELLA, MICHAEL721CA 10-00339(2006-4045)
GIBSON, JEFFREY D., PEOPLE v204KA 08-00891(I2005-2678)
GOLDEN, RODNEY v BROWN, JAMES P.794CA 09-02639(I-2006-3496)
HARRIS, KENNETH L. v CITY OF BUFFALO,810CA 10-00124(I 2007-7984)
HARRIS, DARIUS, PEOPLE v801KA 09-00540(I2007-2384)
HERNANDEZ, LUIS, PEOPLE v820KA 08-02135(I2006-1534)
HILL, SPENCER, PEOPLE v688KA 08-02637(I2007-1253)
J., CYNTHIA v P., DAVID C.698CA 09-02620(2007/9950)
JOHNSON, KIMBERLY v CANTIE, FRANK500CA 09-01064(I2006-11594)
JOHNSON, SHANNON L. v YARUSSI CONSTRUCTION, INC.,655CA 09-01993(2005-6258)
JOHNSON, TERRANCE, PEOPLE v441KA 07-02677(I00031-2007)
LAUFFER, ALYSIA J. v MACEY, JENNIFER L.768CA 10-00234(2007-6330)
LIEBEL & MERLE SALES, INC., v POLYMER CONVERSIONS, INC.,593CA 09-02500(I 2005-8897)
LORENZO, DAWN M. v KAHN, M.D., KENNETH R.302CA 09-01027(I2000/10059)
LYMAN, RICHARD v TOWN OF AMHERST,792CA 09-02267(I2004-11950)
MANCUSO, JULIE J. v KOCH, M.D., TODD B.567CA 09-00893(2001/9618)
MANCUSO, JULIE J. v KOCH, M.D., TODD B.568CA 09-00894(2001/9618)
MEEGAN, JR., ROBERT P. v BROWN, BYRON W.762CA 09-01748(6718-2008)
MEEGAN, JR., ROBERT P. v BROWN, BYRON W.763CA 09-01749(6718-2008)
NAZARIO, EDWELL, PEOPLE v730KA 09-01190(I2008-2466)
ORLANDO, ROCCO C. v GAUDA, ROGER C.741CA 10-00304(I2006-11835)
P., SERENITY, MTR. OF824CAF 09-00969(NN-18659-08, NN-18660-08
PAONE, VINCENT, PEOPLE v755KA 09-01188(I2007-2463)
PIERI, SR., DUANE v B&B WELCH ASSOCIATES,542CA 09-02328(2006-9035)
PRUCHNICKI, JR., DANIEL, PEOPLE v759KA 09-00833(I2007-1895S)
RODRIGUEZ, ADA v WESTERN REGIONAL OFF-TRACK BETTING,742CA 09-02342(I2009-5357)
S., DEVRE, MTR. OF808CAF 09-00627(NA-4991-92-08)
SAFFORD, JERMAINE, PEOPLE v781KA 08-02242(I2006-3040)
SHAPARD, CHRISTOPHER M., PEOPLE v727KA 09-00749(I2006-0178)
SIMON, STEPHEN, PEOPLE v821KA 09-00922(I2007-00950)
STEGURA, MICHELLE T. v FOX, SCOTT M.722CA 09-02115(2007-011349)
STOJEK, JANICE M. v CLEAR-ALL,851CA 09-02246(I2007-2104)
T., MAJERAE, MTR. OF693CAF 09-01376(NN-14239-08)
THE NEW KAYAK POOL CORPORATION, v KAVINOKY COOK, LLP,813CA 10-00073(2007-860)
TOM GREENAUER DEVELOPMENT, INC., v BURKE BROTHERS CONSTRUCTION, INC.,595CA 09-02502(I 2004-9153)
TRONOLONE, DANIEL G. v JANKOWSKI, BERNARD F.478CA 09-02372(2007-5201)
VEGA, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v777KA 09-00793(S30271)
W., ELIZABETH, MTR. OF696CAF 09-00543(NN-03363-08, NN-03364-08
WILLIAM, BASKWALI, PEOPLE v710KA 09-00510(I2008-0718)
YARGEAU, ALICE v LASERTRON,725CA 09-02211(2008/013494)
YARGEAU, ALICE v LASERTRON,724CA 09-02102(I2006-13494)
YOUNG, MALCOLM, PEOPLE v856KA 09-00390(I2008-1406)
 
Genesee
BAKER, KEVIN, PEOPLE v728KA 09-01369(S09-043)
E., RYAN M., PEOPLE v776KA 09-01368(I WY-5706)
KIRKUP, ROBERT, PEOPLE v798KA 08-02469(S08-065)
PIECHOCKI, III, ROBERT v TOWN OF ALEXANDER,736CA 10-00220(57850)
WILLIAMS, ROBERT L., PEOPLE v780KA 09-00160(I5091)
 
Herkimer
SUTTON, APRIL J. v SUTTON, JOSEPH E.787CAF 09-02630(V-00841-08/08AB)
 
Jefferson
PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK v LAWRENCE, SR., JAMES238CA 09-01671(2008-3041)
RODRIGUES, SARA N., PEOPLE v759.1KA 09-00196(I08-014-08)
TAITT, FRANCES J. v SNELLING, CHARLES D.769CA 09-01406(2006-843)
TAITT, FRANCES J. v SNELLING, CHARLES D.770CA 09-01408(2006-843)
 
Livingston
DAVIDSON, LAURALEE v COACH USA, INC.,748CA 10-00070(131-2007)
DAVIDSON, LAURALEE v COACH USA, INC.,749CA 10-00072(131-2007)
L., JR., JAMES, MTR. OF672CAF 09-01855(S-1335-08)
L., JR., JAMES, MTR. OF673CAF 09-01857(S-1335-08)
ROACH, MICHAEL v COACH USA, INC.,747CA 10-00069(131-2007)
ROACH, MICHAEL v COACH USA, INC.,746CA 10-00068(131-2007)
 
Monroe
ALLIED BUILDERS, INC., v GREECE CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,127CA 09-01415(2006-06007)
ALLIED BUILDERS, INC., v GREECE CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,128CA 09-01417(6007-06)
ANDERSON, ROBERT K. v GREAT EASTERN MALL, L.P.,635CA 09-01229(13221-03)
BRYANT, KEVIN C., PEOPLE v711KA 10-00250(2003/392)
C.P. WARD, INC., v DELOITTE & TOUCHE LLP,771CA 10-00039(2000/8356)
DEACON, ARRINE O., PEOPLE v756KA 07-01957(I2006-0908)
ESSLER, SHAWN, PEOPLE v775KA 10-00291(2008-0960)
GILBERT, JENNIFER, PEOPLE v707KA 07-01648(I07/94)
GOLDSTEIN, D.D.S., NEIL v BROOKWOOD BUILDING CORPORATION,717CA 10-00121(07/6649)
GUTIERREZ, JOSE, PEOPLE v779KA 03-02419(I2002-0223)
HENNER, MICHAEL v EVERDRY MARKETING AND MANAGEMENT,676CA 09-01832(06-11603)
HENNER, MICHAEL v EVERDRY MARKETING AND MANAGEMENT,677CA 09-01833(2006/11603)
JEFFERSON, DONNELL, PEOPLE v622KA 08-02121(I92-0053)
LABAR, JODI S. v MOSEZELL, PHILLIPS849CA 10-00350(2644-08)
LETMAN, DERICK, PEOPLE v819KA 07-01380(I06/716)
MANCUSO, CHRISTOPHER M., PEOPLE v804KA 07-01488(I2006/0139B)
MCKEE, MARGUERITE v PLONSKY, STEVEN679CA 09-02113(2008/5729)
MONTALVO, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v778KA 09-00292(2006/511) & (I2006-0016)
NILSEN, PATRICK R., PEOPLE v796KA 09-00277(I2006-0346)
OPHARDT, ANDREW v VASQUEZ, JULIO591TP 09-00945(08/013191)
OPHARDT, ANDREW v VASQUEZ, JULIO592CA 09-01337(08-13191)
PARRIS, ULYSEES, PEOPLE v842KA 08-01203(I2005-0712)
POE, HEIDI v POE, MARK C.719CA 10-00060(2006-05661)
PORTER, MICHAEL T. v NESBITT, JULIE A.695CAF 09-00640(V-10508-06/08A)
ROUSE, JACOB, PEOPLE v758KA 07-00127(I2006-0235)
SAMPSON, DEMETRIUS F., PEOPLE v862KA 08-00486(I2006-0550)
SCHREIBER, DEAN v UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER MEDICAL CEN,743CA 09-02275(2001-004198)
SCHUYLER, DOLORES N. v STRONG MEMORIAL HOSPITAL,654CA 09-01854(15497-06)
STEVENS, TERRY L. v ALLIED BUILDERS, INC.,630CA 09-02563(12363-08)
X-MED, INC., v WESTERN NEW YORK SPINE, INC.,297CA 09-01693(07-10414)
YELDER, JR., ORLANDO, PEOPLE v800KA 08-01374(I2006-0266B)
 
Niagara
ALLEN, GILBERT H. v KALEIDA HEALTH,830CA 10-00181(127053)
BANKS, RODNEY, PEOPLE v691KA 09-01326(I2007-545)
BARTO, DAVID A. v NS PARTNERS, LLC,472CA 09-02417(130235)
CHAFFEE, JENNIFER v LOCKPORT MEMORIAL HOSPITAL,854CA 10-00044(126524)
COLEMAN, CLYDE v ISG LACKAWANNA SERVICES, LLC,764CA 10-00340(121359)
CROSS, CORNELIUS, PEOPLE v686KA 09-01365(I2004-141)
MARKEL, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v752KA 09-01285(I2008-384)
MARTINO, JENNIFER D. v STOLZMAN, MICHAEL A.651CA 09-02359(131926)
PERNA, MICHAEL R., PEOPLE v726KA 09-01045(I2007-201-V)
PERNA, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v731KA 09-01046(I2007-201)
SEVENSON ENVIRONMENTAL SERVS., INC., v THOMAS JOHNSON, INC.,613CA 09-02516(129354)
WALLACE, LICIA A., PEOPLE v795KA 09-01201(I2006-027-V)
WORKMAN, SR., ANTHONY G., PEOPLE v684KA 09-00475(I2005-406)
ZARAGOSA, GILBERT, PEOPLE v835KA 09-00204(I2007-064-1)
 
Oneida
ADZAJLIC, ALEN, PEOPLE v860KA 09-02036(I04-155)
FULLER, CHRISTOPHER E., PEOPLE v685KA 08-01923(II07-335)
H., SEAN, MTR. OF783CAF 09-00816(B-04711-06/08D,)
KOSS, WLODEK v MICHAUD, CHRISTINE L.645CAF 09-02237(V-00508-07/08E)
MURAD, JACQUELYN E. v RUSSO, JOSEPHINE761CA 10-00156(CA2008-000831)
PINK, RAYMOND v RICCI, MATTHEW656CA 09-02395(2008-423)
RAMIREZ, ADELYN v VELAZQUEZ, ERIC L.629CAF 09-00738(V-02561-08, V-02562-08)
S., FRANCHESCA L., MTR. OF826CAF 09-01576(B-04992-05, B-04993-05)
SITTS, JOSEPH B. v SITTS, ALLISON L.479CA 09-02607(D2008-043805)
THE INDIUM CORPORATION OF AMERICA, v MCP GROUP SA,740CA 10-00112(2009-934)
 
Onondaga
FERRIS, SR., JON DENNIS v BENBOW CHEMICAL PACKAGING, INC.,772CA 10-00109(2008-2706)
GILLIAM, TYSAMOE T., PEOPLE v799KA 08-02609(I2005-0055-1-V)
GRUNINGER, MICHAEL v NATIOINWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPAN,637CA 09-02001(2007-6335)
GUIFFRIDA, MICHAEL v STORICO DEVELOPMENT, LLC,829CA 10-00300(2005-3142)
H., MICAH, MTR. OF784CAF 09-01572(B-7801-08)
RODRIGUEZ, JUAN, PEOPLE v836KA 07-01177(SI-2001-0648-1-V)
SCERBO, ALBERT, PEOPLE v559KA 09-01688(I2007-383-1)
SCHWIMMER, PHILIPPE R. v ROTH, JOAN716CA 09-02298(2007-4498)
SCHWIMMER, PHILIPPE R. v ROTH, JOAN715CA 09-02297(2006-5892)
SIMCOE, HAROLD, PEOPLE v837KA 08-01518(I2007-1002-1)
SOMMERS, III, ALBERT C., PEOPLE v754KA 08-00521(I2007-0966-1)
WHITING, LAURIE J. v PALUMBO, JOSEPH846CAF 09-01907(F-01758-02/08I)
WYNIT, INC., v SMARTPARTS, INC.,473CA 09-02469(2009-2240)
 
Ontario
ANTHONY, ROBERT E., PEOPLE v713KA 08-01142(I07-07-107)
COLON-VELAZQUEZ, FRANKIE C., PEOPLE v709KA 08-01683(I06-10-139)
COLON-VELAZQUEZ, FRANKIE C., PEOPLE v704KA 08-01684(I06-10-138)
CONSILIO, CARYN, PEOPLE v733KA 10-00030(08/01-027)
GANNETT CO., INC., v DORAN, CRAIG J.699OP 09-02287
HUNT, RACHEL L., PEOPLE v581KA 08-00893(I07-07-095)
POTTER, STEPHEN N., PEOPLE v687KA 09-01459(I08-10-146)
 
Orleans
DASH, RANDY L., PEOPLE v839KA 08-02481(I08-32)
EIBL, LISA v SNYDER, STEVEN760CA 10-00253(06-32224)
SHANNON, ARCHIE v KHAHAIFA, SIBATU864KAH 09-00045(08-35058)
 
Oswego
BRAND, NORBERT F., PEOPLE v705KA 09-01023(I06C-237)
KENNEDY, THOMAS R., PEOPLE v802KA 10-00158(08-110)
WOOLWORTH, JOAN, MTR. OF701CA 10-00127(06248)
 
Seneca
ALSTER, STEVEN v FISCHER, BRIAN750TP 09-02568(43160)
HAQUE, ANWAR v LEMPKE, JOHN751TP 10-00263(43324)
 
Steuben
JOHNSON, CONNIE L. v ROSE, JOSHUA G.850CA 09-02524(99047)
STILES, MATTHEW v EDWARDS, JILL M.875.1CAF 09-02618(V-00454-06/09B,C,D)
 
Wayne
KONSTANTINOU, GEORGE v PHOENIX INSURANCE COMPANY,811CA 10-00162(61775)
LOUDER, III, FRANKIE, PEOPLE v803KA 09-00274(I08-107)
SANCHEZ, RABI R., PEOPLE v706KA 07-00806(I06-48)
TAFT, NADIA v VILLAGE OF NEWARK PLANNING BOARD,790CA 09-02276(62612)
 
Wyoming
JOHNSON, MARK v STATE OF NEW YORK,870CA 09-02112(105385)
POWELL, CALVIN v NYS DEPT CORRECTIONAL SERVICES,692KAH 08-01509(20,636-08)
 
Yates
BORUM, CORI A. v BORUM, DAVID865CAF 09-01730(V-00352-08)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS