AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - October 1, 2010

ACCURSO, NINA A. v KLOC, NICOLE M.933CA 10-00561(2008-0110)
AMERICAN DIABETES ASSOCIATION, v ABBEY, MECCA & CO., INC.,992CA 10-00388(2007-12579)
ANDRUS, EDWARD, PEOPLE v924KA 09-01246(I2007-341)
ANGELICOLA, ROBERTO v PATRICK HEATING OF MOHAWK,973CA 09-01405(2005-001312)
ARIEL, RAFIQA v ARIEL, JR., DONALD1021CAF 09-01877(V-20745-08/08A)
B., WHYTNEI, MTR. OF1001CAF 09-00699(B-7436-07, B-1279/80-07)
BAKER, ROBERT v COUNTY OF OSWEGO,1008CA 10-00507(06-0285)
BANK OF UTICA, v CITY OF SYRACUSE,993CA 10-00603(09-1939)
BATCHATEU, BEST v PETERS, DAVID R.1025TP 09-02097(2009/5932)
BATJER, SCOTT, PEOPLE v920KA 10-00875(0398/07)
BERMUDEZ, VINCENT, PEOPLE v925KA 07-01379(I438/06)
BIRD, JOHN J. v BIRD, VICKIE L.1047CA 09-01404(73548)
BORK, MARGUERITE D., PEOPLE v919KA 07-01565(II06-335)
BOWLER, SANDRA v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HU,1044TP 10-00767(136596)
BRADBURY, GREGORY v MONAGHAN, GENEVA1108CAF 10-00128(V-08013-08, V-08014-08)
BRADBURY, GREGORY v MONAGHAN, GENEVA1109CAF 10-00129(V-08013-08/09A,)
BREAN, RENEE L. v LOVE, RICK D.1033CA 10-00564(15421-07)
BROWN, TRISHA v ARNOT MEDICAL CENTER,1050CA 10-00225(96518)
CANNON, GEOFF v COR RIDGE ROAD COMPANY, LLC,1096CA 09-01527(2006/9286)
CAPODIFERRO, NICOLE M. v CAPODIFERRO, ROBERT A.1136CA 09-02453(D2006-42923)
CARPENTER, ROBERT M. v NY ADVANCE ELECTRIC, INC.,1005CA 10-00497(I300030/2009)
CARSON, GENERAL v WILLIAMS, MELVIN1041KAH 10-00166(42,602)
CARSON, JEFFREY M. v TOWN OF OSWEGO,970CA 09-02320(2008-0539)
CARUANA, MARY v PADMANABHA, M.S., BHAVANSA953CA 10-00787(I2008/6426)
CHATT, LEON, PEOPLE v926KA 08-01135(I2006-1940)
CHILBERT, MICHELE S. v SOLER, ARCHANGEL L.1083CAF 09-01914(V00521-09)
CHILBERT, MICHELE S. v SOLER, ARCHANGEL L.1088CAF 09-01915(O-00418-09)
CHUCK TOMASELLI, DOING BUSINESS AS, v ONEIDA COUNTY INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMEN,964CA 10-00396(2008 -410)
COLLIER, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v954KA 09-01283(I08-157)
COOPER, CARL M., PEOPLE v1102KA 08-02521(I2008-0792)
COOPER, CARL M., PEOPLE v1101KA 08-02522(I2008-0239)
COUNCIL, NAHSHON AARON v UTICA FIRST INSURANCE COMPANY,1119CA 10-00775(08-8191)
CRANE-HOGAN STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS, INC, v ESLS DEVELOPMENT, LLC,945CA 10-00527(3728/08)
CRAVATTA, MICHAEL J. v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSP, ORTATION1078CA 10-00770(13429-08)
CRUMP, JR., RICHARD A., PEOPLE v997KA 09-01820(I08-358-08)
CURELLA, DOUGLAS J. v TOWN OF AMHERST,944CA 10-00614(2008-3209)
D'ANGELO, STEPHANIE v LITTERER, ANDREA S.1034CA 10-00709(2008-5890)
DAVIS, BRANDON L., PEOPLE v927KA 07-01265(I2006-0395)
DIAZ, JUAN, PEOPLE v1125KA 09-02345(I6046)
DINATALE, ROBIN v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN,1003TP 09-01922(007734/2009)
DOSANJH, HARWANT, MTR. OF1010CA 10-00433(08-0896)
DRURY, PHILLIP v VILLAGE OF NORTH SYRACUSE,1064TP 10-00459(2010-0027)
E., ZANNA, MTR. OF1022CAF 09-00541(NA03057-07, NA03056-07)
EASTMAN KODAK COMPANY, v CARMOSINO, ROBERT1121.1CA 10-01062(2010/02022)
EBERLE, JAN v HUGHES, III, M.D., THOMAS F.1076CA 09-01908(I 2007-554)
FANTIGROSSI, JR., JAMES F. v BRANNON HOMES, INC.,1094CA 10-00414(2007/8118)
FUREY, SCOTT, PEOPLE v1016KA 10-00766(08c-138)
GALLO, PAULINE v RIESKE, MELINDA1004CA 10-00391(2006-8778)
GENEVA CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT, v ANONYMOUS, A TENURED TEACHER,1024CA 10-00465(101900)
GIARDINA, SHARON J. v LIPPES, RICHARD J.929CA 09-02251(2003-8028)
GOD OF THUNDER PRODUCTIONS, LTD, v STAROPOLI, ALESSANDRO985CA 09-01686(2008-1493)
GRAHAM, KATHERINE A., PEOPLE v1144KA 10-01007(I 10C-13)
GRAHAM, DARRELL, PEOPLE v1123KA 09-00320(I2007-1641)
GRAHAM, RICHARD L., PEOPLE v1145KA 10-01008(I 10C-12)
GRAHAM, DARRELL, PEOPLE v1124KA 09-00577(I2007-2735)
GRAY, STEVE J., PEOPLE v955KA 10-00748(331/08)
GUERESCHI, DANIEL v FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK,1046CA 09-02586(2007-8699)
H., ALFONSO, MTR. OF1089CAF 09-01293(NN-00063-09)
HARRIS, GEORGE L., PEOPLE v940KA 08-02540(I2008-0381)
HARRIS, JR., FRED, PEOPLE v979KA 09-01483(S31665)
HAYES, KELLY v NORSTAR APARTMENTS, LLC,987CA 10-00643(2008-4007)
HENDERSON, LYNN, PEOPLE v958KA 07-01866(I2007-0078)
HOUSE, MARLIN, PEOPLE v996KA 09-01554(I08-88)
INNTEL MANAGEMENT CORPORATION, v CITY OF CANANDAIGUA,984OP 10-00167
J., ALEXANDRA, MTR. OF942CAF 09-00874(NN-15539-08, NN-15540-08
JAMES SYRACUSE LLC, v GAMAGE, JOHN C.1012CA 10-00582(2005-2338)
JAMES SYRACUSE LLC, v GAMAGE, JOHN C.1014CA 10-00584(2006-2552)
JAMES SYRACUSE LLC, v GAMAGE, JOHN C.1013CA 10-00583(2006-2551)
JOHNSON, DARRELL, PEOPLE v1126KA 08-02228(I2006-2843)
JONES, JR., DENNIS D., PEOPLE v961KA 06-02499(I2006-0498-1)
K., GEORGE, MTR. OF941CAF 09-01595(NN-15606-15611-2008)
KABALAN, GABRIELE v HOGHOOGHI, DDS, ALEXANDER1009CA 09-02247(125851)
KALKMAN, LAURIE, COULTER, GEOFFREY R. v928CA 09-02444(1994 DT 00316/B)
KARCZ, JR., JOHN W. v KLEWIN BUILDING COMPANY, INC.,1026CA 10-00858(123582)
KIDDER, MARY v MOORE, LARRY947CA 10-00445(I2008-003378)
KNOPE, OLGA v KNOPE, GERARD S.968CA 10-00342(2007-13482)
LAIDLAW ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL, v TOWN OF ELLICOTTVILLE,1053CA 10-00136(2007-6628)
LAPE, HOLLY v WILLIAM GOLDBACH, ROLLINS, INC.,950CA 09-01673(I2008-3876)
LAVANN, IVOIRE v BELL, JACOB1106CAF 09-00890(O-14709-08)
LEONE, DONALD v BRASON, DAVID1069CA 10-00651(2009-040)
LEWIS, SUE Y. v TOWN OF RICHLAND,1098CA 10-00395(08-2267)
LOVELESS FAMILY TRUST, v KOENIG, PAUL1135CA 10-00249(57585) & (65785)
LYON, BRIAN P., PEOPLE v999KA 08-01365(I07-10-115)
M., DEONDRE, MTR. OF1020CAF 09-01735(B-10735-08)
M., JUSTYCE, MTR. OF1085CAF 09-01777(NN-05050-09, NN-05054-09
MACON, MARCUS M., PEOPLE v939KA 07-01633(I2006-0954C)
MAGIC CIRCLE MUSIC, LTD., v STAROPOLI, ALESSANDRO1112CA 10-00729(2008-1408)
MARGOLIS, JANE L. v VOLKSWAGEN OF AMERICA, INC.,972CA 08-02012(2002-4089)
MARGOLIS, JANE L. v VOLKSWAGEN OF AMERICA, INC.,967CA 10-00049(4089/02)
MARRIOTT, ALFRED F. v TOWN AND VILLAGE OF LOWVILLE ZONING,1091CA 10-00354(CA2009-000212)
MATEO, DAMIAN J., PEOPLE v1037KA 09-00921(I04-10-105)
MATTAR, LAWRENCE JOSEPH v HECKL, ROSANNA E.1061CA 10-00206(SF 2006-902242)
MAY, LEE O., PEOPLE v1057KA 09-00601(I1628-2005)
MCDONELL, KYLE P. v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF MOTOR, VEHICLES1043TP 10-00878(2867-2010)
MCDUFFIE, JAMAR, PEOPLE v1018KA 09-01917(I2008-0502)
MCFARLEY, JR., JAMES, PEOPLE v922KA 07-01489(I2000-0455)
MCMILLON, JR., ANDRE M., PEOPLE v1038KA 09-00533(I502/2008)
MEDLER, PATRICK, PEOPLE v1082KA 09-00698(I2008-0787-1)
MENDEZ, JOSE, PEOPLE v960KA 07-00416(I0442/06)
MILLER, BRIAN v MILLER, JENNIFER1084CAF 09-02613(F-04420-06A-D)
MILLER, ANDREW J., PEOPLE v1056KA 07-02427(I95-116)
MIRANDA, ISRAEL, PEOPLE v974KA 05-00500(I2003-0354)
MITCHELL, LATEIK, PEOPLE v1039KA 05-00257(I559/2003)
MONSAY, EVELYN H. v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN,1042TP 10-00790(10-276)
MORGAN, LOUIS, PEOPLE v1103KA 09-00604(I2007-2648)
MUDHOLKAR, GOVIND S. v THE UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER,1027CA 10-00761(09-05950)
NEW YORK STATE NURSES ASSOCIATION,, v COUNTY OF ERIE,1079CA 10-00094(11671/2008)
NICHOLS, JUSTIN, PEOPLE v1000KA 09-00003(I2007-120A)
NICHOLSON, DAMON v A. ANASTASIO & SONS TRUCKING CO., I,988CA 10-00093(40650)
NIXON, WINNIE, PEOPLE v1128KA 08-02273(I2007-2076)
O'BRIEN, DAVID M., PEOPLE v1129KA 09-01837(I08-112)
OGDEN, PHYLLIS G. v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF,1065TP 10-00363(2009-6615)
OWENS, LARRY, PEOPLE v1059KA 09-00720(I2008-01300R)
PAGE, FRANCIS v PAGE, JEAN ELLEN1110CAF 10-00297(F-16926-08/08B)
PARR, RUBEN v MONGARELLA, ANDREW J.1117CA 09-01655(06-524)
PAYNE, ALMA D. v R-D MAINTENANCE UNLIMITED, INC.,937CA 09-02103(122247)
PEAY, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v956KA 08-01670(I07-01-006)
PETERSON, HELEN v DAINES, M.D., RICHARD F.1063TP 10-00736(2010-0031)
PETT, VICTOR, PEOPLE v921KA 08-01665(II08-007)
PINO ALTO PARTNERS, v ERIE COUNTY WATER AUTHORITY,946CA 09-02596(I2006-11957)
PLUNKETT, DAVID, PEOPLE v1127KA 09-01437(I06-063)
POLIZZI, DDS, GAETANO J. v IPPOLITO, MS, DDS, ANTHONY J.1072CA 10-00227(I2007-011026)
PRATT, COLLEEN, PEOPLE v998KA 09-01887(S09-20)
PURCELL, JULIE v JEFFERSON COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY,986CA 10-00710(07-6925)
R., EDUARDO, MTR. OF983CAF 10-00735(D-10215-09)
R., ELEYDIE, ERIE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, SERVICES v1107CAF 09-01596(B-15445-08,)
RADKO, MARIE v BANWAR, M.D., NITIN S.948CA 10-00516(6755-03)
RAUCH, SAHRINA H. v KELLER, BRIAN W.1087CAF 09-02190(V-04744-05/09C)
RICHARDSON, JAMES E. v MURRAY TOWN COURT,969CA 09-02266(09-36574)
RIPKA, JOANN v RIPKA, ROBBIE1051CA 09-01605(2006-0089)
RLI INSURANCE COMPANY, v SMIEDALA, LESLIE931CA 09-02296(130744/07)
ROBINSON, DAVID U. v BROADSPIRE SERVICES, INC.,936CA 09-02510(I2005-10829)
RODRIGUEZ, ALBERTO v FISCHER, BRIAN918TP 10-00042(43396)
ROGERS, PENNY v SHERMAN, WILLIAM1114CA 10-00397(2006-1535)
ROLL, GARY S. v GAVITT, ASHLEIGH A.1092CA 10-00099(101646)
ROY, DONNA L., PEOPLE v957KA 08-02546(II07-450)
RUSH, EUGENE, PEOPLE v1019KA 07-01909(I2006-0686)
SCHAEFER, BETTY v TOWN OF VICTOR,1007CA 10-00074(99549)
SCHENK, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v1100KA 09-00495(I2005-2310)
SCHRADER, DENITA v SCHRADER, DANIEL1111CA 10-00576(103660)
SELTZER, LAWRENCE v CITY OF ROCHESTER,943TP 10-00789(2009-2093)
SEMRAU, RICHARD, PEOPLE v1122KA 07-01855(I02368-2006)
SHAMPINE, NORMAN, PEOPLE v923KA 07-00810(03-0983) & (I694-02)
SHARLOW, JAMIE WURZ v SHARLOW, JR., ROBERT1118CA 10-00526(2006-042976)
SHIRE, SHARMARKE, PEOPLE v1017KA 09-00740(I2008-0718)
SHROUT, KIMBERLY A. v ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATIO, N1032CA 09-02560(2003/7032)
SIMMONS, ERIK, PEOPLE v1015KA 09-02346(I5959)
SIMPSON, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v963KA 06-03432(I44/06)
SINGH, PAUL D., PEOPLE v980KA 10-00711(I-08-152)
SLADE, AARON S. v HOSACK, TONYA S.1086CAF 08-02490(V-748-06/08B, C)
SMIELECKI, WILLIAM J., PEOPLE v1104KA 08-02355(I00026-2008)
SMOLINSKI, THOMAS J. v SMOLINSKI, MATTHEW A.994CA 10-00714(5874/01)
SNYDER, MARGARET v PLANK, DONALD991CA 10-00510(360-2009)
SPINOSA, LANCE v BECK, CHARLES F.1113CA 09-01282(2007-1097)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v FLAGG, DANIEL1079.1CA 10-00776(08C0001)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v WILKES, HAROLD1141CA 09-01471(M 543,946-08)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v WILKES, HAROLD1142CA 09-01472(M 543,946-08)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v WILKES, HAROLD1143CA 09-01474(M 543,946-08)
STEARNS, ADAM R. v O'BRIEN, IRENE1049CA 10-00352(100093)
TAG MECHANICAL SYSTEMS, INC., v V.I.P. STRUCTURES, INC.,965CA 10-00649(2004-2520)
TESMER, MONICA v COLONNA, DAVID951CA 10-00708(07-33761)
THOMAS, BRETT H., PEOPLE v976KA 08-02001(S07C-214)
TIRADO, KANDIS v KORITZ, SARA H.1029CA 10-00511(I-2008/6198)
TODD, CAROL ANN v MORRISON, ALISTAIR CHARLES1105CAF 10-00864(F-06037-08)
TONZI, CAROL A. v NICHOLS, RICHARD H.1140CA 10-00408(59082)
TONZI, CAROL A., MTR. OF1139CA 10-00407(59082)
TOWNSEND OIL CORPORATION, v MARINI, ANTHONY L.1099CA 10-00868(56071)
TRACY, DALE R., PEOPLE v1080KA 09-01502(I08C-111)
TRANE, MARK v HASTEE, JAMES R.1030CA 10-00874(I28055)
TRZASKA, THOMAS J. v ALLIED FROZEN STORAGE, INC.,935CA 09-02509(2007-000871)
TRZASKA, THOMAS J. v ALLIED FROZEN STORAGE, INC.,930CA 10-00760(2007-0871)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1132CA 09-02429(I2004-2110)
TURNER, STEPHEN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1133CA 09-02575(2004-2110)
V., ALEXIS, VANDUSEN, WILLIAM v1014.2CAF 10-00115(V-10569-09/09BN)
VAILLANT, ALEXANDER, PEOPLE v1060KA 09-02414(S31563)
VANDUSEN, WILLIAM v RIGGS, MELISSA L.1014.1CAF 09-01397(V-10569-99/08BM)
VANLARE, KENNETH, PEOPLE v962KA 09-01048(I08-120)
VELOCITY INVESTMENTS, LLC, v COCINA, EVE MARIE952CA 09-02514(I-2007-1915)
VICENS, ORLANDO, PEOPLE v1058KA 09-00496(I1993-W-0064)
WACHOVIA DEALER SERVICES, INC., v HARDEE, JAMES L.934CA 10-00472(2009-931)
WATKINS, JAMES, PEOPLE v1081KA 09-00349(II08-275)
WEBB, JOHN v BOCK, CHARLES A.1097CA 09-02159(07-183)
WINDSONG LANE FARMS, v TELMARK, LLC,1075CA 09-01973(2004-2341)
WINDSONG LANE FARMS, v TELMARK, LLC,1074CA 09-01972(2004-2341)
WINDSONG LANE FARMS, v TELMARK, LLC,1073CA 09-01685(2004-2341)
WISNIEWSKI, STEVEN, PEOPLE v981KA 09-02570(S30465)
WISNIEWSKI, STEVEN, PEOPLE v975KA 09-02569(I2007-0931)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS