AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - November 12, 2010

ABBUHL, HOWARD A. v AMERICU CREDIT UNION,1208CA 10-01182(CA2009-000914)
ALESSIO, JENNIFER v BURCH, HAROLD1368CAF 09-02494(O-13555-09)
A., AKEIRA, MTR. OF1363CAF 09-02493(NN-03857-09)
A., BABY GIRL, MTR. OF1227CAF 09-01388(NA-02470-09)
ALLEN, BRANDON O., PEOPLE v1176KA 07-01843(I2006-0769A)
ALOI, STEVEN, PEOPLE v1221KA 10-00165(I08-017)
ALOI, STEVEN, PEOPLE v1220KA 09-01255(I08-017)
ARCHIE, DEREK L., PEOPLE v1247KA 09-02640(I2009-042)
AYLSWORTH, DONNA M. v KOWALCZYK, GREGORY1160CA 10-00542(SF-1999-901097)
B., ROSEMARIE v C., CAROL1278CAF 09-01656(V-01009-09)
BARNES, MONTRELL A., PEOPLE v1275KA 09-01765(I08-DI-027)
BENTON, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v1219KA 10-00605(I02002-2008)
BETTS, CYNTHIA A. v TOWN OF MOUNT MORRIS,1328CA 10-01176(452-2007)
BOIVIN, WAYNE A. v THE MARRANO/MARC EQUITY GROUP,1265CA 10-01186(2007-6331)
BOND, GEOFFREY v TURNER, THOMAS A.1045CA 10-00746(K1-2008-889)
BONILLA, MIGUEL v NASH, MICHAEL1334KAH 10-01002(43045)
BOWERS, NATHANIEL B., PEOPLE v1218KA 09-00159(S08-DI-169)
BRAY, KIMBERLY v DESTEVENS, ROBERT1253CAF 09-01767(V-00249-98/09T)
BRINK, RONALD, PEOPLE v995KA 08-02649(I08-01-022)
BROWN, MARY v MONROE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, SERVICES971CA 10-00501(2004-2039/A)
BUNTING, JOHNNY v GOORD, GLENN S.1146TP 09-01446(0936335)
C., ANNASTASIA, CATTARAUGUS COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF, SOCIAL SERVICES v1284CAF 09-01567(NN-1565-08)
C., ANNASTASIA, MTR. OF1290CAF 09-01566(NN-1566-08; NA-1569,)
C., LOKI, MTR. OF1285CAF 09-01568(NA-1567, 1568-08)
CALDWELL, MICHAEL D., PEOPLE v1248KA 08-02470(I2006-0966A)
CALLENDER, AARON v FISCHER, BRIAN1169TP 10-01277(20910-10)
CARRASQUILLO, CHRISTOPHER v SEB DEVELOPMENT, LLC,1331CA 10-01009(2006-8329)
CASE, THOMAS V. v CASE, ANTONE R.1348CA 10-00567(297-2003)
CASELLA, ROBERT v CITY OF ROCHESTER,1327CA 10-01269(09-16229)
CHIARAPPA, WILLIAM, PEOPLE v1357KA 09-00507(SI-2007-0442-V-1)
CHRISTOPHER, STEVEN v STATE OF NEW YORK,1209CA 09-01780(108185)
CITY OF SYRACUSE INDUSTRIAL, DEVELOPMENT AGENCY v HESS CORPORATION,1178CA 09-00624(2008-4242)
CLARKSON, DOUGLAS, PEOPLE v1276KA 09-01276(I2007-108)
CONSUMER SOLUTIONS REO, LLC, v GIGLIO, JOHN A.1344CA 10-00005(2008-1827)
COPP, FLORENCE, PEOPLE v1225KA 09-01516(I2008-491-1)
COR BROKERAGE, INC., v NEW HARTFORD SHOPPING CENTER TRUST,1350CA 10-01167(2009-66844)
COUNTY OF ONONDAGA, v MAYOCK, BRIAN1397TP 10-01168(2010-1733)
COX, HENRY, PEOPLE v1274KA 09-00201(I2007-0925A)
CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC., MURPHY, JOHN v1213CA 09-02450(I2004-680)
DANIELS, BURNIE, PEOPLE v1316KA 09-00726(I5107)
DAVIS, MARLIN v HOSPITALITY MOTELS USA, INC.,1288CA 10-01263(2006-128110)
DEAN, LAMARCUS, PEOPLE v1271KA 08-00030(I416/07)
DEVANE, TRAVIS V., PEOPLE v1298KA 09-01511(I276-08)
DONALD, RONALDO M., PEOPLE v1273KA 09-00939(I2008-0568)
DRAMAN, SHANE M. v NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF CHILDREN A,1333TP 10-01166(2010/2888)
DRENNEN, MICHAEL, MTR. OF1185CA 10-00950(2009-1093)
DYE, JR., MARVIN, PEOPLE v1340KA 09-01555(2003-253)
EATON, FAYE M. v WAYNE TEACHERS ASSOCIATION,1306CA 10-00528(2009-6118)
ENDRES, EUGENE v MOSEY, ACEY M.1310CA 10-00901(2006-011/A)
EXTALE, JAMES, PEOPLE v1174KA 08-00786(I2004-1076)
FAC CONTINENTAL LLC, v YICKJING567 LLC,1157CA 10-00269(I2007-12419)
FAC CONTINENTAL LLC, v YICKJING567 LLC,1156CA 10-00268(I2007-12419)
FISHER, AARON RICHARD, PEOPLE v1339KA 06-03538(I303/06)
FRANCIS, STEPHEN P., PEOPLE v1246KA 08-02679(II08-090)
FREEMAN, MATTHEW, PEOPLE v1149KA 07-00535(I2006-0765-2)
GARTH, LEONID G. v BENET, LISA1286CA 10-00586(101451)
GILBERT, NATHANIEL, PEOPLE v1293KA 09-00596(I0540-S01)
GRANDALL, ROBERT v FETHERS, TRACY1255CAF 09-02187(V00802/803-09)
H., MIKIA, MTR. OF1279CAF 09-01726(B-124-127-2008)
HADSELL, MARK K., PEOPLE v1295KA 09-01145(S08-107-V)
HANSEN, JAMES B. v CAROUSEL CENTER COMPANY, L.P.,1256CA 10-00065(2004-4764) & (2004-4764A)
HARNANTO, JOSHUA M. v GANDASAPUTRA, YVONNE1186CAF 09-02255(V-04710-09/09B,)
HAYES, LEROY v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF CORREC,1314KAH 10-00951(20,859-09)
HEATON, LISA v MONROE COUNTY,1093CA 10-00591(2009-01213)
HENDERSON, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v1150KA 07-00132(I2006-0237-1)
HOWARD, KEIKO v ROBB, PATRICK J.1309CA 10-00964(132037)
HULIHAN, WILLIAM, ROLF, DONALD v1148TP 10-00888(CA2009-003463)
IPPOLITO, MS, DDS, ANTHONY J. v POLIZZI, DDS, GAETANO J.1322CA 10-00318(I2009-008315)
JACKSON, LOUIS J. v BEACH, DEBBRA K.1226CAF 09-00991(V-78-00/08Y, V-78-00/08Z
JOHNSON, CHARLES T., PEOPLE v1224KA 09-00860(I2007-0966)
JONES, WILLIE J., PEOPLE v1319KA 07-00402(I2005-0769-1)
K., CODY, MTR. OF1387CAF 09-02080(A-136-09)
K., NOREON, MTR. OF1280CAF 09-01675(B-00126-08, V-03001-08)
KENNEDY, TROY L., PEOPLE v959KA 09-01166(I2008-087)
KHUNS, SUSAN C. v BAY STATE INSURANCE COMPANY,1090CA 10-00231(04/11301)
KING, CHRISTINE L. v FOSTER, WILLIAM P.1251CAF 10-00890(V-04232-04233-07/09B)
KINNEAR, LLOYD F., PEOPLE v1318KA 10-00929(08-10-119)
L., STEVEN, MTR. OF1366 CAF 09-02183 (AS-19939-05/08A,)
LANCASTER, JASON v NASH, MICHAEL1315KAH 10-01010(43046)
LASTER, KEITH, PEOPLE v978KA 06-00673(I2005-622)
LASTER, KEITH, PEOPLE v977KA 06-00672(I2000-466)
LAURICELLA, JR., SALVATORE v LAURICELLA, SAMANTHA1367CAF 10-00835(F-06602-09)
LONGHINE, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v1171KA 09-02052(T-5768)
LORENTI, MARK v STICKL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC.,1329CA 10-01185(134438)
LUTZ, BETSY v STERLING, JASON1207CAF 09-02307(V-05909-95/09H)
LYONS, PHILIP J. v STATE OF NEW YORK,1330CA 09-02343(113617)
MACWILLIAMS, MARGUERITE v MACWILLIAMS, ROBERT1205CAF 09-02496(F-01145-04/09E)
MADILL, JAMES W., PEOPLE v1338KA 09-00822(I03-500-03-V)
MARGETIN, RUSSELL v JEWETT, JR., ROBERT T.1011CA 10-00782(2003-6628)
MARTIN LUTHER NURSING HOME, INC., v DOWLING, MICHAEL J.1374CA 10-01013(94-10581)
MATT, RICHARD W., PEOPLE v1360KA 08-01373(I1998-012)
MCCANN, KARA R. v HARLEYSVILLE INSURANCE COMPANY OF N,1179CA 10-00612(I2007-10372)
MCCANN, KARA R. v HARLEYSVILLE INSURANCE COMPANY OF N,1180CA 10-00613(I2007-10372)
MCCORMICK, TIMOTHY P. v 257 W. GENESEE, LLC,1291CA 10-00437(I-2007-1539)
MCCRAY, JR., BRYANT C., PEOPLE v1321KA 09-02188(I09-23)
MCKEON, JR., RICHARD J., PEOPLE v1361KA 09-00580(I08-23)
MELLON, DEBORAH v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS,1236CA 10-01235(139321)
MOHAWK VALLEY WATER AUTHORITY, v STATE OF NEW YORK,1165CA 10-00688(2005-928)
MOHAWK VALLEY WATER AUTHORITY, v STATE OF NEW YORK,1166CA 10-00689(CA2005-000928)
MOORE, JOSHUA C. v MOORE, DESIREE1385CAF 09-01265(V-00559-08,)
MORRICE, KEVIN R., PEOPLE v1200KA 10-01195(07-04-070)
MORRIS, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v1356KA 08-02630(I2007-2798D)
MORRISON, PATRICK, PEOPLE v1359KA 07-01486(I2006-970)
MURCH, SCOTT v FIRST UNITED METHODIST CHURCH OF CA, NANDAIGUA1305CA 10-00321(07/00180)
MURPHY, JOHN v CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC.,1214CA 09-02452(I2004-680)
NATIONAL URBAN VENTURES, INC., v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS,1184CA 10-00673(134497)
NATIONAL URBAN VENTURES, INC., v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS,1190CA 10-00675(134497)
NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN, v INDEPENDENT AUTO APPRAISERS, INC.,1212TP 10-00994(09/10545)
NEW YORK STATE THRUWAY AUTHORITY, v KTA-TATOR ENGINEERING SERVICES,1257CA 10-00474(I-2004-11115TP1)
O'CONNOR, LYNDA, PEOPLE v1244KA 08-00491(I2007-0312-5, SCI
ONE NIAGARA LLC, v CITY OF NIAGARA FALLS,1237CA 10-01283(137559)
OWENS, ANTWON, PEOPLE v1154KA 07-00578(I2006-235)
OZOLINS, REBECCA E. v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF CORREC,1313TP 10-00364(43602/2009)
PALASZYNSKI, PAMELA v MATTICE, BEVERLY J.1189CA 10-00722(56825)
PALASZYNSKI, PAMELA v MATTICE, BEVERLY J.1188CA 10-00639(56825)
PFAFFENBACH, NATHAN v NEMEC, DOUGLAS J.1031CA 10-00749(I2008-6645)
PICCIONE, GEORGE, PEOPLE v1173KA 09-00173(I00158-2008-S01)
PONHOLZER, DONNA v SIMMONS, EDWARD1071CA 10-00740(I2004/5867)
PORCELLI, SUSAN, MTR. OF1323CA 09-01969(2006-1840)
POVOSKI, JR., FRANK J., PEOPLE v1198KA 07-01225(I2005-0040)
R.-A., JEZEKIAH, ERIE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL, SERVICES v1228CAF 09-01389(NA-11876-77-08)
REED, CYRUS Y., PEOPLE v982KA 09-00284(I08-082)
REED, CHARLES, PEOPLE v1194KA 07-02558(I2007-0415B)
REED, CHARLES, PEOPLE v1199KA 07-01033(I06-123)
RICHEY, CHANELLE C. v HAMM, MARY LOU1332CA 10-00194(2009005005)
RIDER, HAROLD L. v CORRIGAN, KAREN1396CAF 10-00980(F-01378-09/09)
RIGGS, MELISSA L. v VANDUSEN, WILLIAM1282CAF 10-00114(F-04587-07/08C)
RIVERA, HECTOR L., PEOPLE v1379KA 09-00493(I1995-W-0012)
ROMANELLO, ANNE M. v FINLAY, KENNETH S.1349CA 10-00411(2008-7356)
ROTH, NORMAN E. v CITY OF SYRACUSE,1311CA 09-02503(2001-2698) & (2002-3223)
RUFFINS, AARON L., PEOPLE v1382KA 09-02019(0036-2008)
SALSBERY, SHAUN M., PEOPLE v1377KA 09-01795(I08C-202)
SANTIAGO, JOSE J., PEOPLE v1216KA 07-02349(I210/99)
SAWYER, NICHOLAS, PEOPLE v1172KA 08-02464(2007-012295) & (I2007-0780)
SCHNEIDER, JEFFREY M., LOMANTO, LISA L. v1203CAF 09-01781(F-03814-08/08B)
SCHNEIDER, JEFFREY M., LOMANTO, LISA L. v1204CAF 09-01782(F-03814-08/08B)
SCOTT, CHARLIE J., PEOPLE v1196KA 08-00136(I2006-0913)
SHERMAN, DAVID D., PEOPLE v1355KA 10-00788(09C-101)
SILLS, ROBERT v ROYSTON, JOAN1369CA 10-00577(86951/79987)
SILLS, ROBERT v ROYSTON, JOAN1370CA 10-01098(86951/79987)
SINGLETON, WILLIE J., PEOPLE v1036KA 08-02018(I07-10-118)
SMITH, DAMION, PEOPLE v1292KA 07-00800(I99-2384-001)
SNOW, BERNARD, PEOPLE v1362KA 07-01925(I2006-0969)
SOLER, FRANCISCO v FISCHER, BRIAN1147TP 10-01276(20907-09)
SPARCINO, JOSEPH G., PEOPLE v1153KA 10-01128(08-1429)
STANISTREET, BRADLEY R., PEOPLE v1296KA 09-00616(II07-366)
STILES, RONALD K., PEOPLE v1272KA 09-02088(S2009-156)
SUBURBAN TOOL & DIE CO., INC., v CENTURY MOLD COMPANY, INC.,1192.1CA 10-00785(2008/15399)
SULLIVAN, SHAWN v RGS ENERGY GROUP, INC.,1095CA 10-00682(2007/12462)
SWARTZ, DERRICK A. v KALSON, VICTOR F.1232CA 10-01003(I 2008-2846)
SYMONDS, JR., HAROLD D. v BERLIN, BETH1354TP 10-01194(2010-566)
T.-L., SHARDANAE, MTR. OF1386CAF 09-01634(NA-1546-08)
TOWN OF ONONDAGA, v RITTER, DIANA JONES1168TP 10-01232(2010-1909)
UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, v MCATEER & FITZGERALD, INC.,1354.1CA 09-02448(2002-000808)
UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, v MCATEER & FITZGERALD, INC.,1354.2CA 09-02449(2002-000808)
VANANTWERP, JONATHON A., PEOPLE v1197KA 09-02278(S2009-162)
VELEZ, LUIS A., PEOPLE v1177KA 04-01659(I2003-0094C)
VERIZON NEW YORK, INC., v STATE OF NEW YORK,1324CA 09-01684(112333)
W., AUDRIANNA, MTR. OF1277CAF 09-02035(NN-02173-08, NN-02174-08
W., AYODEJI, MTR. OF1252CAF 09-02045(B00583-09)
W., SYIRA, MTR. OF1231CAF 09-01862(NN-09776-78-2008)
WAHL, GARY A. v COUNTY OF WAYNE,1343CA 10-00974(68382)
WALTZ, JAMES T. v VINK, MARY S.1372CA 10-01091(101007/08)
WARE, ELLIS LEE v EVANS, ANDREA1210TP 10-00958(20921-10)
WASHINGTON, DENNIS, PEOPLE v1195KA 09-00856(I2008-1432)
WASHINGTON, JR., JAMES E., PEOPLE v1299KA 06-03139(I2004-1148B)
WATTS, PEREZ, PEOPLE v1317KA 09-02436(I2008-533)
WEST, RANDALL v FORTEQ NORTH AMERICA, INC.,1267CA 10-00347(2007/5931)
WEST, RANDALL v FORTEQ NORTH AMERICA, INC.,1268CA 10-00348(2007/05931)
WEST, RANDALL, MTR. OF1266CA 10-00345(2007/05931)
WHITED, ANDREW N., PEOPLE v1384KA 08-00155(I2006-0188)
W., SYIRA, MTR. OF1231CAF 09-01862(NN-09776-78-2008)
WILLIAMS, LUSHAWN A., PEOPLE v1151KA 09-01577(I2007-1951)
WILLIS, ERIC, PEOPLE v1335KA 09-02303(I2009-101)
WINIARSKI, RICHARD v HARRIS, M.D., LINDA1239CA 10-00490(2007/3375)
WINIARSKI, RICHARD v HARRIS, M.D., LINDA1238CA 10-00374(2007/3375)
WINIARSKI, RICHARD v HARRIS, M.D., LINDA1240CA 10-00585(2007/3375)
YOONESSI, MAHMOOD v GIVENS, DEBRA L.1373CA 10-00578(I2003/9143)
ZENZILLO, JANINE v UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYD'S LONDON,1211CA 10-00886(CA000535/06)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS