AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - April 29, 2011

ABASCIANO, FRANK v DANDREA, PATRICK522CA 10-02439(08/15164)
ADGER, LAMAR O., PEOPLE v612KA 09-01801(I2008-1024B)
ALTSHULER SHAHAM PROVIDENT FUNDS, L, v GML TOWER LLC,557CA 10-01745(2008-9348)
AQUINO, THOMAS A., PEOPLE v506KA 10-00325(S08-26 (restitution))
B., NICHOLAS, MTR. OF620CAF 10-00705(B-16830,1-08, B-16383,4-
B., WILLIAM C., MTR. OF601CAF 10-00596(B-19021-08)
B., WILLIAM C., MTR. OF602CAF 10-00597(B-19021-08)
BAILEY, MICHAEL D., PEOPLE v508KA 10-00313(S09-DI-223)
BARONE, ROBERT J. v PHILLIPS, SUSAN RAYNOR474CA 10-02362(K1-2007-1816)
BELLANTI, YVONNA, PEOPLE v438KA 10-01578(2887I-2007)
BINETTE, GERRY, CANADY, LAUREN KELSO v541CAF 09-00644(V-00595-06/06A)
BLAKE, JANE RENNIE v BLAKE, KENNETH DARCY450CA 10-01699(4497/1991)
BLAKE, JANE RENNIE v BLAKE, KENNETH DARCY449CA 10-01698(4497/1991)
BOATMAN, MARLON, PEOPLE v481KA 08-02107(I2003-631-20)
BONES, COREY, PEOPLE v459KA 10-00400(I2002-0607)
BROTHERS, JASON L. v CHAPMAN, HEATHER L.621CAF 10-00294(V-00061-03/09A)
BROWN, COREY A., PEOPLE v591KA 10-01111(I09-90)
BRUBAKER, JASON A. v HOUSEKNECHT, MARIANNE M.519CA 10-02378(134240)
BUCHANAN, RACHEL T. v DOMBROWSKI, MATT433.2CA 10-02086(2008-8413)
BUCHANAN, RACHEL T. v DOMBROWSKI, MATT433.1CA 10-02055(I 2008-008413)
BULSON, RICHANDA J. v GRINNELL, DAVID R.515CAF 10-00148(F-04507-06/08A)
BURGDORF, JOSEPH D. v KASPER, KENNETH G.545CA 10-02393(136722)
BURGIO, ROBERT M. v CITY OF LOCKPORT,564CA 10-02404(134271)
BURTON, DARYL L., PEOPLE v556KA 10-00758(I2009-080)
C., ALEX A., MTR. OF516CAF 10-00838(NN-01368-09/09B)
C., THOR, MTR. OF603CAF 10-00916(NN-902-09)
CARBAJAL, VICTOR M., PEOPLE v437KA 08-01187(I2006-0926)
COLLINS, BRIAN, PEOPLE v597KA 09-02442(I2006-0622)
COLON, RIVAS v FISCHER, BRIAN434TP 10-02181(44489)
COUNTY OF ERIE, v DAINES, RICHARD F.445CA 10-02128(2009-8127)
COUNTY OF HERKIMER, v DAINES, RICHARD F.451CA 10-02129(91120)
DAVIS, ANTOINE, PEOPLE v348KA 10-00464(I2008-1870D)
ELLICOTT GROUP, LLC, v STATE OF NEW YORK EXECUTIVE DEPT.,563CA 10-02269(10684/2009)
ELLIOTT, JAMES, PEOPLE v484KA 09-02347(I5254)
ELLISON, ROBERT, PEOPLE v507KA 08-02218(I2007-0591A)
FARO, FREDERICK M., PEOPLE v567KA 09-00278(I2008-0011)
FERRELL, SR., RUSSELL A. v FERRELL, SUSAN L.622CAF 10-00706(V0054/0055-07/09CDE)
FREDENDALL, BRIEN, PEOPLE v531KA 10-01258(I2009-244)
FS KIDS, LLC, v COMPENSATION RISK MANAGERS, LLC,609CA 10-01807(I2008-11268)
GLENEAGLES SHOPPING CENTER PLANO, v FITNESS EVOLUTION, L.P.,315CA 10-02215(2010-1596)
GODLEWSKI, ROBIN v CARTHAGE CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT,578CA 11-00017(2008-00003313)
HARRIS, BARRY v EASTMAN KODAK COMPANY,559CA 10-02405(9688/2088)
HARRISON, JERMAINE, PEOPLE v549KA 10-01174(I09-DI-061)
HAUKE, SUSANNE, PEOPLE v439KA 10-00556(S09-DI-067)
HENDERSON, WILLIAM A., PEOPLE v482KA 10-00175(S09-075)
HERDENDORF, CHRISTINA L. v GEICO INSURANCE COMPANY,468CA 10-01676(2008/4117) & (2008/10231)
HERDENDORF, CHRISTINA L. v GEICO INSURANCE COMPANY,469CA 10-01677(2008/4117) & (2008/10231)
HERNANDEZ, NICOLE v TOWN OF HAMBURG,447CA 10-01296(2005-10162)
HERNANDEZ, ORLANDO, PEOPLE v596KA 07-00531(I0498/2006)
HOBBY, CALVIN, PEOPLE v514KA 08-00656(I401/07)
HORAN, GINNETTE v TOWN OF TONAWANDA,562CA 10-02522(I2008-3278)
HORN, DALE R., PEOPLE v465KA 10-01222(I2009-0100A)
HORN, DALE R., PEOPLE v466KA 10-02399(I2009-0100B)
HOWARD, RUSTIN R. v BIOWORKS, INC.,606CA 10-02497(103418)
HOWARD, CHRISTOPHER M., PEOPLE v509KA 10-01621(I2009-614-1)
HYDE, RENEE v NORTH COLLINS CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRI,546CA 10-02520(I 2007-4037)
JAMES, DORSEY, PEOPLE v547KA 07-01781(I2005-0156-3)
JERGE, ALAN G. v PENN-AMERICA GROUP, INC.,277CA 10-02188(I 2009-3940)
JEWETT, VICKI v M.D. FRITZ, INC.,582CA 10-02338(2007-12650)
JOHNSON, ROBERT, PEOPLE v462KA 06-03763(I2006-0682-1)
JOHNSON, ROBERT, PEOPLE v461KA 06-03762(I2006-0537-1)
KENDRA, CHRISTIAN, PEOPLE v554KA 10-00184(I2008-0332)
KILBURY, KEITH, PEOPLE v595KA 07-01561(I2006-0601-1)
KIMBALL, JR., RONALD v NORMANDEAU, JR., LAWRENCE E.473CA 10-02309(09-0122)
KIRKLAND, WESLEY, PEOPLE v480KA 08-01038(I2007-0950)
KRIEGER, JOANN v COGAR, VICKY543CA 10-02006(135471)
KURKOWSKI, CHARLES, PEOPLE v617KA 10-01579(2008-03178)
L., JASON, PEOPLE v553KA 10-01492(I2009-180B)
L., LEPORIA L., MTR. OF517CAF 10-02043(D-01748-09)
LAMAR, ANTHONY C., PEOPLE v532KA 10-00699(I09-50)
LESTER, JERMAINE, PEOPLE v594KA 08-00132(I0808/06)
LITZENBERGER, GARY D., PEOPLE v573KA 10-01146(I3719B)
LUGO-ROSADO, ORLANDO, PEOPLE v487KA 09-00588(I91-0327-1)
M., CHEYENNE, MTR. OF599CAF 10-01710(NN-15490-09)
MARGERUM, EUGENE v CITY OF BUFFALO,587.1CA 11-00157(2007/1462)
MAULL, DAVID L., PEOPLE v464KA 10-00519(I08-113)
MAULL, DAVID L., PEOPLE v458KA 10-00518(I08-159)
MAYER, WILLIAM J. v HOANG, HENRY470CA 10-02471(I2009/1454)
MCAFEE, SHARON v MCAFEE, JAMES448CA 10-01975(66556)
MCCARTHY, RONALD E., PEOPLE v511KA 09-00027(I07C-172)
MCCOLLUM, THEODORE, PEOPLE v440KA 10-01076(I04-DI-003)
MCGINNIS, ERIC J., PEOPLE v616KA 08-00858(I2007-0481)
MCGOUGH, NICHOLAS J., PEOPLE v530KA 09-01935(S09-DI-047)
MERCER, JACOB J., PEOPLE v485KA 10-02133(I03165-2009)
MOORE, DUSTIN M., PEOPLE v536KA 10-00825(S09-071)
MULLEN, RICHARD v STATE OF NEW YORK,479CA 10-02353(116118)
NAPPI, DONATO, PEOPLE v615KA 10-00826(I09-037)
NEWBOULD, DAVID W., PEOPLE v572KA 10-01435(I09-95)
NIAGARA MOHAWK POWER CORP., v TOWN OF NIAGARA ASSESSOR,584CA 10-02303(116279)
OAKES, ROBERT C. v BIELER ENTERPRISES, INC.,566CA 10-02087(08-0913)
ORTMAN, JENNIFER, PEOPLE v179KA 09-00992(I08-10-108)
OTT, ANTHONY N., PEOPLE v412KA 06-01424(I2005-0717A)
PREDMORE, PAUL M. v BANAZEK, STANLEY454CA 10-02379(2009-1279)
PROGRESSIVE NORTHEASTERN INSURANCE, v FARMERS NEW CENTURY INSURANCE COMP,471CA 10-01743(I-2007-1763) & (I-2006-10095)
PUMP, STEPHEN D. v EKPE, EKPE D.528TP 10-02372(08-A-0492)
R., CAYDEN L., MTR. OF537CAF 10-01326(B-1010-09)
R., NICHOLAS J., MTR. OF289CAF 10-00914(NA-01003-09)
ROBBINS, TRACEY, PEOPLE v505KA 09-00980(I2007-2536)
ROCKWOOD, RUSSELL J. v LABATE, JAMES500CA 10-02321(2009-91039)
RUSSELL, KARON R., PEOPLE v455KA 08-01137(I2007-0484A)
RUSSELL, KARON R., PEOPLE v460KA 08-01138(I2007-0588B)
SCAMACCA, FRANK v LEON, DOLORES585CA 10-01957(2007-3456/B)
SCOVAZZO, GENEVIEVE v TOWN OF TONAWANDA,625CA 10-02403(2010-3967)
SELAK, MICHAEL v CLOVER MANAGEMENT, INC.,604CA 10-02139(132296)
SENECA PIPE & PAVING CO., INC., v SOUTH SENECA CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRIC,521CA 10-01953(34140)
SENECA PIPE & PAVING CO., INC., v SOUTH SENECA CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRIC,520CA 10-01952(34140)
SHUBERT, ANDREW P., PEOPLE v593KA 10-01015(I08-7874)
SINCLAIR, CHASE, PEOPLE v611KA 08-00653(S2007-3328)
SMITH, JOHN F. v REILLY, MARIJANE404CA 10-02274(2008-6154)
SMITH, ANDRE, PEOPLE v457KA 08-00840(I90-0907-1)
SPENCER, TONY L., PEOPLE v589KA 10-00727(I2008-171)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v KEAR, TERRY560CA 10-01230(30660)
STEPHAN, DAVID v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE COMPA,587CA 10-02504(2009-12357)
TAYLOR, DEVEN R., PEOPLE v443KA 08-02471(I2007-0790)
THE TRAVELERS INDEMNITY COMPANY, v ELLIOTT COMPANY,453CA 10-02373(2005-7032)
THOMPSON, JANELL, PEOPLE v551KA 08-00885(I2006-0275E-A)
THOMPSON, GREGORY J., PEOPLE v512KA 10-01151(I09-75)
THORPE, CYNTHIA v CHAPELSKY, GEORGE JAMES630CA 09-02487(038454-2004)
TULLOCH, CLIFFORD, PEOPLE v548KA 10-00606(I2009-0578)
TUTTLE, JR., WILLIAM, PEOPLE v483KA 10-01267(I2009-39)
VANNEST, JONATHAN D. v SOUTH SHORE MARINA, LLC,446CA 10-02059(060802)
VARGAS, RITCHIE v STATE OF NEW YORK,475CA 10-00935(111449)
VAZQUEZ, FERNANDO v MAIN STREET USA REAL ESTATE GROUP,501CA 10-02492(08-0066)
VERHOW, BARRY K., PEOPLE v486KA 09-02521(I00-14)
VIEIRA, LIONEL T. v HUFF, DIANE P.472CAF 10-00275(V-02718-02/09Y)
W., DEAMARI, MONROE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN S, v203CAF 10-00236(B-01690/91-09)
W., TYLER, MTR. OF540CAF 09-01386(NN-06518-07, V-14153-08)
WELSHER, ADAM J., PEOPLE v569KA 08-02026(I2006-0770)
WEST, GERALD, PEOPLE v442KA 09-02655(I08-07-091)
WESTON, JAMEL, PEOPLE v456KA 08-00830(I2006-0987-1)
WILLIAMS, DIETRICH, PEOPLE v568KA 10-00558(I5259)
WILLIAMS, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v571KA 07-01844(I2006-0595)
WOLTZ, NANCY v FIGUEROA, M.D., JEANETTE L.565CA 11-00027(2006-5261)
WORTH, DOUGLAS, PEOPLE v534KA 06-00414(I1993-0993)
WORTH, DOUGLAS, PEOPLE v535KA 09-01449(I1990-0142)
YUSON, MORRIS B., PEOPLE v435KA 08-00834(I2007-0455)
ZICKL, ANNE N. v DAINES, M.D., RICHARD F.598TP 10-01858(59959)
    
MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS