AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - September 30, 2011

ABDUS-SAMAD, SAIFUDDIN v GRAHAM, HAROLD D.1033TP 11-00634(2010-0959)
ALBRIGHT, MICHAEL v MALIN, TAYLOR D.890CA 11-00183(2008-2825)
ALBRIGHT, MICHAEL v MALIN, TAYLOR D.889CA 10-01697(2008-2825)
APPLEWHITE, CHRIS v GRAHAM, HAROLD D.879KAH 10-00962(2009-0985)
BAKER, JERMAINE v FISCHER, BRIAN878TP 11-00462(21,008-10)
BAKER, RICKY, PEOPLE v929KA 10-01917(I09-134)
BAKER, RICKY, PEOPLE v928KA 10-01916(I09-127)
BECK, AVIS M. v BUTLER, ROBERT LEONARD1054CAF 10-02459(O-01193-10)
BELL, LAWRENCE, PEOPLE v902KA 10-00804(S32764)
BENTON, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v908KA 11-00115(02002-2008)
BENTON, LASHONDA, PEOPLE v949KA 08-01925(SI-2007-0537-1)
BILLUPS, TRAVIS W., PEOPLE v950KA 10-00557(I2008-3192)
BROWNLEE, DEREK v GUTZMER, CARL A.865CAF 10-01066(O-00047-08)
BRYANT, THOMAS, PEOPLE v863KA 10-01129(I5885)
BUSKE, CANDY, PEOPLE v973KA 08-00431(SI-2007-0764-1)
CAMERON, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v989KA 10-00828(S32273)
CAMERON, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v990KA 11-00801(S32273)
CANFIELD, DENISE M. v CANFIELD, CHRISTOPHER V.864CAF 10-01831(V-00197-09 A&B,)
CASTLETON DEVELOPMENT, LLC, v GREENMAN-PEDERSEN, INC.,921CA 11-00361(139700)
CICCOTTI, DAVID v THOMPSON, STEPHANIE955CAF 10-01944(V-06381-04/10L)
CICCOTTI, DAVID J. v THOMPSON, STEPHANIE A.954CAF 10-01672(O-06114-09)
COLDIRON, LON, PEOPLE v1015KA 09-01941(I2004-2596)
COMACHO, PEDRO J., PEOPLE v995KA 09-01584(I2008-0776A)
COMMISSIONER OF DEPARTMENT OF SOCIA, v JONES, JERRELL J.T.870CAF 10-02365(F-000912-09/10A)
CRANE, LOGAN D., PEOPLE v1018KA 10-00179(I09-04-090)
CROUGH, PATRICK v B.J.'S WHOLESALE CLUB, INC.,1000CA 11-00429(2009-4451)
CUMMINGS, PATRICIA A. v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF MOTOR,966TP 11-00735(2011-001211)
CURTO, PATRICIA J. v DIEHL, MARK1005CA 10-02026(2008-13090)
CURTO, PATRICIA J. v DIEHL, MARK1004CA 10-02025(2008-13090)
CURTO, PATRICIA J. v DIEHL, MARK1003CA 10-02024(2008-13090)
D'ANGELO, STEPHANIE v LITTERER, ANDREA S.981CA 11-00425(2008-005890)
DAVIS, ROBERT, PEOPLE v951KA 07-02656(I2006-0787-1)
DEAN, LAVON, PEOPLE v946KA 10-01599(I08-2128)
DEFORGE, JOHN v KARWOSKI, LYNDI939CA 11-00653(2009-4807)
DEMCHIK, CHARLES v COUNTY OF NIAGARA,888CA 10-02515(138199)
DEVOGELAERE, ERIN v WEBSTER ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS,1048CA 11-00506(2010-14692)
DEWINE, MARK H. v STATE OF NEW YORK BOARD OF EXAMINER,918CA 11-00774(2010-C0047)
DILLARD, ALICIA v HILL, DERRICK934CAF 10-01548(V-15705-09)
DOMBROWSKI, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v861KA 10-00213(I2006-02332)
E., CHASE J., MTR. OF974CAF 10-01317(N-592-09)
E., JACOB, MTR. OF933CAF 10-00915(B00369-09)
EDWARDS, WILLIAM v FISCHER, BRIAN945TP 11-00552(21012-10)
EMMERLING, CRAIG J. v TOWN OF RICHMOND,897TP 11-00294(103803)
EVANS, KEVIN v FISCHER, BRIAN857TP 11-00553(20935-10)
FARM FAMILY CASUALTY INSURANCE COMP, v BRADY FARMS, INC.,941CA 10-02440(55464)
FAYETTE, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v991KA 10-01110(I09-393-09)
FEWELL, CHRISTOPHER v KOONS, JENNIFER M.1041CAF 10-01240(V-00700-06/09C)
FRAZIER, JOSEPH P., PEOPLE v970KA 10-00535(I94-1328-001)
FULMER, DESHAUN R., PEOPLE v1017KA 11-00105(I2010-0100-1)
G., ADAM, MTR. OF956CAF 10-01384(NA-1876-1878-09)
GARTH, VICTORIA G. v ASSESSORS OF TOWN OF PERINTON,910CA 11-00004(2008/16083)
GIACOMETTI, AMY G. v DOYLE, SHANNON M.940CA 11-00537(127487)
GILMER, DEMERUS, PEOPLE v862KA 07-01622(I2006-0668)
GILPIN, GARY W. v OSWEGO BUILDERS, INC.,1032.1CA 11-00042(07-1297)
GLOVER, DEVIN J., PEOPLE v1016KA 08-01205(I2006-0946)
GREECE TOWN MALL, LP, v MULLEN, DENNIS M.1049CA 11-00471(2010/8714)
GRYBOSKY, STANLEY S. v RIORDAN, DAWN M.957CAF 09-01654(V-17883-6/08D)
H.H. WARNER, LLC, v ROCHESTER GENESEE REGIONAL,1026.2OP 11-01202
H., ANGEL L., MTR. OF978CAF 10-01521(N-2820-2821-09)
HANKS, TERRIS, PEOPLE v994KA 08-01129(I2007-0992-4)
HARMON, KALVIN v GRAHAM, HAROLD909KAH 10-01915(2009-1435)
HELLES, TONYA v HELLES, SR., LUKE866CAF 10-01016(V-927/931-08/09D)
HELLES, TONYA, MTR. OF868CAF 10-01019(0-01416-09/10A,)
HELLES, TONYA v HELLES, SR., LUKE867CAF 10-01018(O-01416-09)
HOUGHTALING, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v906KA 10-02157(I2004-072)
HOUGHTALING, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v905KA 10-02041(I2004-071)
IKEDA, PATRICIA v TEDESCO, DANIELLE M.898CA 10-02480(CA2007-001248)
INTERNATIONAL GROUP, INC., v UNITED STATES AVIATION UNDERWRITERS, INCORPORATED966.1CA 11-01089(ef2011/600442)
J., ELIZABETH, MTR. OF1042CAF 10-01603(B-05429-08/09A)
JENNINGS, JERMAINE, PEOPLE v860KA 08-01361(I2007-0846-3)
JOE, QUINTRELL L., PEOPLE v859KA 08-00219(I2007-0390-2)
JONES, STEPHEN v FISCHER, BRIAN967TP 11-00463(21,001-10)
JONES, CHARLES N., PEOPLE v881KA 10-00802(I2008-2011)
KAUFMANN'S CAROUSEL, INC., v CAROUSEL CENTER COMPANY LP,959CA 10-02444(06-7497) & (06-7498)
KING'S COURT RESTAURANT, INC., v HURONDEL I, INC.,986CA 11-00391(2009-14669)
L., LASTANZEA, MTR. OF976CAF 10-00594(B-03433-07)
L., LASTANZEA, MTR. OF975CAF 10-00593(B-03433-07)
LAMBERTSON, JACOB E., PEOPLE v927KA 10-02197(I5353)
LAVILLA, STEPHEN P., PEOPLE v993KA 09-01469(I5152)
LEAVINES, DAVID v HUEBER-BREUER CONSTRUCTION CO., INC,877CA 11-00558(08-9387)
LICCIARDI, MARK A. v CITY OF ROCHESTER,1011TP 11-00777(10/3016)
LITTLE, DANIEL A. v TOWN OF FABIUS ZONING BOARD OF APPE,987TP 11-00759(11-12)
LOGRASSO, MICHAEL J. v CITY OF TONAWANDA,1026CA 11-00423(06-06017)
LOGRASSO, MICHAEL J. v CITY OF TONAWANDA,1026.1CA 11-00978(06-06017)
LUGO, MICHAEL C., PEOPLE v1038KA 08-01709(I2006-0966B)
LYNCH, JAMES v CORCORAN, MICHAEL P.883KAH 11-00261(2008-1557)
MALACHOWSKI, RONALD A. v DALY, MARTIN J.938CA 11-00054(CA-2005-001687)
MARCERA, LORI v MARCERA, MICHAEL871CA 10-02433(2006/8517)
MASTERPOL, JOSEPH M. v COUNTY OF ONONDAGA,985CA 11-00436(2007-0889)
MASTROCOVO, COLLEEN v CAPIZZI, JOEL893CA 11-00714(2006-902927)
MCGEE, DEMETRIUS, PEOPLE v1034KA 09-01054(I2008-1258)
MERRILL LYNCH CREDIT CORPORATION, v SMITH, DOUGLAS P.1028CA 11-00729(2008-16992)
METZGIER, MICHAEL v MILLER, ABE A.1052CA 11-00394(00088562)
MILLER, JOSHUA L., PEOPLE v907KA 10-00467(I09-14)
MONROE, FREDERICK v FISCHER, BRIAN901TP 11-00551(21036-10)
MORAN, JOSEPH v MUSCARELLA, JR., D.O., JOSEPH L.900CA 10-02148(I2006-008631)
MORAN, RABAH E., PEOPLE v925KA 08-01253(I2007-0500)
MOSS, CONNIE v BATHURST, SHIRLEY A.1001CA 11-00743(140667)
MYERS, JAMES R. v MYERS, DIANE C.1029CA 11-00003(99890)
MYERS, MICHAEL W., PEOPLE v882KA 10-01759(I96-032 & I96-187)
NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN, v NANCY POTENZA DESIGN & BUILDING,988TP 11-00646(2010-011134)
NEWMAN, RODNEY M., PEOPLE v968KA 10-02037(I09-65)
NIEMANN, ERICA L. v ST. JOSEPH'S HOSPITAL HEALTH CENTER,1030CA 11-00662(2007-8718)
NORTON, DARNELL, PEOPLE v923KA 08-02581(I2007-0925B)
O'BRIEN & GERE LIMITED, v NEXTGEN CHEMICAL PROCESSES, INC.,872CA 11-00776(2008-9164)
PATTERSON, KRISTIAN J. v CRISAFULLI, JEANNETTE I.953CAF 10-01629(AS-00189-05/09A 880)
PERCIVAL, VICKI v SAMPLE, JEANNE922.1TP 11-00164(CONF1455)
PHELPS, BEATRICE S. v RANGER, MELISSA A.1020CA 11-00312(CA2008-002824)
PITTS, BERNARD v CULLY, R.858TP 11-00670(1010-2010)
R., PARKER E., MTR. OF1043CAF 10-02162(NN-00101-10)
RINK, RALPH v EXCELLUS HEALTH PLAN, INC.,999CA 11-00410(114132)
ROBERTS, MARK A., PEOPLE v926KA 10-01973(S10C-029)
S., ANNA v R., PEDRO977CAF 10-02525(P-25218-00)
SABIA, MARK V. v NIAGARA MOHAWK POWER CORPORATION,887CA 11-00172(I2009-004988)
SCHROO, JEREMY, PEOPLE v884KA 09-02050(I08-65)
SCOTT, TRACY E. v BERLIN, BETH1010TP 11-00600(2010-3382)
SCRO, ANTHONY v BOARD OF EDUCATION OF JORDAN-ELBRID, GE C.S.D.958CA 11-00781(2010-5786)
SEAWRIGHT, KELVIN v CROOKS, OMAR M.961CA 11-00036(06/8270)
SEAWRIGHT, KELVIN v CROOKS, OMAR M.962CA 11-00570(06/8270)
SPENCER, JOSEPH R., PEOPLE v885KA 07-02180(SI-07-378-06)
SPENCER, JOSEPH R., PEOPLE v880KA 07-02181(I06-378-06)
STANFORD, JAMES RALPH, PEOPLE v992KA 08-00436(I2006-0917)
STARR, JR., JAMES M. v HOLES, ROGER H.1031CA 11-00644(74092)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v REEVE, KEITH1008CA 10-01139(09C0007)
STATE OF NEW YORK, THE PEOPLE OF THE v BLAIR, JOEY942CA 10-01692(35314)
STATEWAY PLAZA SHOPPING CENTER, v ASSESSOR OF CITY OF WATERTOWN,984CA 11-00455(2009-1092)
STEVEN M. GARBER & ASSOCIATES, v ZUBER, KIM JOHN891CA 10-02518(10/8611)
STRANZ, ANNA v NEW YORK STATE ENERGY RESEARCH AND,873CA 11-00424(2005-10316)
STUBINGER, JOHN, PEOPLE v930KA 09-02649(I09-01-028)
T., JOSE, MTR. OF952CAF 11-00371(B-03685-07)
TAYLOR, REGINALD, PEOPLE v924KA 10-00461(I2009-0438)
TAYLOR, REGINALD, PEOPLE v924.1KA 11-00902(2006-1055)
TAYLOR, ANDREW W., PEOPLE v948KA 10-00678(I09-60)
TENCZA, JOHN v ST. ELIZABETH MEDICAL CENTER,1006CA 11-00388(2009-000237)
TESLUK, ALBERT P. v SZYMONIAK, STEPHEN S.1032CA 11-00050(I2009/6719)
TODD, DARLENE v PLSIII, LLC- WE CARE,1007CA 11-00712(137786)
VISCOSI, JOHN v PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY,911CA 11-00508(2008-1126)
W., SEAN, MTR. OF935CAF 10-01355(B-6380-09)
WALKER, GARRETT, PEOPLE v971KA 11-00648(00538-2008)
WEAKFALL, ALEXANDER R., PEOPLE v972KA 08-02134(I2008-0206)
WHITE, LEONARD v FARRELL, DENNIS916CA 11-00578(2006-3638)
WILLIAMS, WENDY v DELTA SONIC CAR WASH SYSTEMS, INC.,943CA 11-00749(123907)
WOODRICH, HAROLD K., PEOPLE v904KA 10-01523(I3094)
WRIGHT, KRISTEN T. v PATAKY, JEFFREY J.869CAF 11-00805(F-19704-06/09E)
WYDRA, PETRA v CITY OF ROCHESTER,1011.1TP 11-00163(2010-13923)
YOUNG, WILLIAM DAVID v CROSBY, MICHAEL R.915CA 10-02477(64271)
ZEMBIEC, THOMAS C. v COUNTY OF MONROE,983CA 11-00330(09-14393)
ZEMBIEC, THOMAS C. v COUNTY OF MONROE,982CA 11-00385(09-14393)
ZUKE, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v886KA 09-02627(S08-DI-191)
      
 MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS