AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - April 26, 2013

A., BRANDON, LIVINGSTON COUNTY ATTORNEY, v231CAF 12-01651(D-00352-12)
A., LESTARIYAH, MTR. OF493CAF 12-00777(B-14395-08)
ALLAH, KHA'SUN CREATOR v PRACK, ALBERT283CA 11-02395(I-2011-01896)
.A, MTR. OF493CAF 12-00777(B-14395-08)
ANDOLINA-STOVCSIK, CHRISTINE v CONESUS LAKE NURSING HOME, LLC,245CA 12-00526(001475-2010)
ANDREWS, TIMOTHY, PEOPLE v545KA 12-00570(S11-099)
ASTACIO, ROBERTO A., PEOPLE v298KA 07-01032(I442A/06)
ATKINSON, PAUL F., PEOPLE v205KA 12-00359(I5472)
B., ANNA, MTR. OF303CAF 12-00562(B-17715-01/11A)
BAILEY, RICHARD, PEOPLE v230KA 11-01381(I2010-103)
BAILEY, RICHARD, PEOPLE v225KA 11-01380(S2010-103C)
BARCLAY, DYLAN, PEOPLE v523KA 12-00447(I5411)
BENDERSON PROPERTIES, INC., v WYNIT, INC.,470CA 12-01998(2009/9411)
BENJAMIN, BRENDA v EDDY, LEONARD F.471CAF 12-01042(V-00058-11/12G)
BOARDMAN, HARRIET v KENNEDY, KATHERINE D.244CA 12-01742(107108)
BOWIE, LONNIE v ERIE COUNTY CHILDREN'S SERVICES,48CAF 12-00097(V-18235-10)
BOYSON, JUSTIN, PEOPLE v229KA 11-01343(I2011-0402-1)
BROWN, CLARENCE R. v DIVELBLISS, MELODY M.234CAF 12-00555(V-00481-08/11C)
BRYANT, KEITH v VENETTAZZI, D.387TP 12-02089(2012-0354)
BUFFALO PROFESSIONAL FIREFIGHTERS, v BUFFALO FISCAL STABILITY AUTHORITY,371CA 12-02126(2011-2839)
BUFFALO PROFESSIONAL FIREFIGHTERS, MTR. OF377CA 12-02127(2005-9450)
BUTLER, WILLIAM J., PEOPLE v323KA 11-01386(I5368)
C., NICHOLAS, MTR. OF305CAF 11-01532(NN-296-10)
CAFFERY, WILLIAM v TIME WARNER CABLE,263CA 12-01837(I2010-10236)
CARROWAY LUXURY HOMES, LLC, v EDWARDS, RICHARD447CA 12-01276(2010-1854)
CHARTER SCHOOL FOR APPLIED TECHNOLO, v BD OF ED FOR CITY OF BUFFALO,1387CA 12-00937(2009-011969)
CHARTER SCHOOL FOR APPLIED TECHNOLO, v BD OF ED FOR CITY OF BUFFALO,1386CA 12-00867(2009-11969)
COLE, MICHAEL A., PEOPLE v525KA 11-00426(S10-DI-050)
COLES, TYQWAN, PEOPLE v226KA 10-02301(I09-07-098)
COLLINS, FREDDIE, PEOPLE v251KA 10-00251(I2009-0038B)
COLVIN, LAWRENCE, PEOPLE v412KA 11-02441(S2010-246)
CONKLIN, CHRISTOPHER, PEOPLE v277KA 12-02083(I2011-01097)
CURETON, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v524KA 11-01285(I2009-2415D)
DEFAZIO, JR., KENNETH J., PEOPLE v394KA 09-02468(S2009-3294)
DEKENIPP, RICHARD A., PEOPLE v204KA 11-00855(I10-04-091)
DONOVAN, ROBERT J., PEOPLE v487KA 12-00856(S11-092)
E., BRANDI, PEOPLE v202KA 09-01366(I2001-0107-1)
EAGLE. JR., AUGUSTUS R., PEOPLE v489KA 10-01012(S2009-3214)
EMSLIE, JAMES v RECREATIVE INDUSTRIES, INC.,139CA 12-01246(2008-6685)
FELDMAN, CARL v LAMPARELLI CONSTRUCTION COMPANY,405CA 12-01945(I2009-12026)
FLAHERTY FUNDING CORPORATION, v JOHNSON, JENNIFER K.427CA 12-02018(11-3583)
FLORES, AMANDA v VESCERA, FRANCIS X.184CA 12-01478(CA2008-000948)
FOOS, BRODY M., PEOPLE v365KA 09-01487(I2008-0616B)
FORSYTHE, MARVIN, PEOPLE v368KA 10-01359(I2005-047)
FRENCH, TERESA v RIVERSHORE INCORPORATED,535CA 12-01792(141661)
G., CALEB, MTR. OF467CAF 11-01882(NN-02641/02644-10)
GABAK, JOHN M., PEOPLE v547KA 11-02543(S11-DI-196)
GARTLER, KENNETH J., PEOPLE v396KA 10-00230(I5201)
GAY, TIMOTHY J., PEOPLE v363KA 11-01780(I10-10-239)
GILES, SHAWN v YI, A. GI59CA 12-01288(08-6299)
GILLETT, JODY B., PEOPLE v418KA 12-00723(I5467)
HALAS, SHAWN v DICK'S SPORTING GOODS, INC.,336CA 12-01868(I2010 9104)
HARTMAN-MCMURRAY, NICOLE, PEOPLE v459KA 12-00214(S6521)
HARVEY, JEUANE, PEOPLE v366KA 08-01776(I2007-0669)
HENNING, JAMES v KING, JR., ESQ., WILLIAM H.452CA 12-01887(2011/4231)
HOLCOMB, DENNIS D., PEOPLE v460KA 12-00133(S11-50)
JOHNSON, WAYNE M., PEOPLE v490KA 09-00205(I2007-0983)
JOHNSON, WAYNE M., PEOPLE v485KA 11-00308(I2007-0918)
K., ANGELINA, MTR. OF33CAF 12-00393(A-03434, 03435-11)
KAHLEY, DALE, PEOPLE v74KA 08-02494(I177-93)
KG2, LLC, v WELLER, BRUCE338CA 12-01225(I2011-001356)
KILLIAN, ALBERT v HEIMAN, KEVIN536CA 12-02077(33813)
KIRKLAND, ERIC, PEOPLE v147KA 11-01835(S11-01-034)
KWITEK, MELISSA v SEIER, FRANCES352CA 12-01607(2010-004370)
LANE, RONDULA, PEOPLE v362KA 11-02040(SS09-134)
LASKEY, DIANE P. v LASKEY, DOUGLAS P.481CA 12-02029(52389)
LAUZONIS, JOSEPH v LAUZONIS, COLLEEN208CA 12-00188(134817)
LEONARD E. RIEDL CONSTRUCTION, INC., v HOMEYER, MICHAEL295CA 12-01715(2008-3037)
LEONARD E. RIEDL CONSTRUCTION, INC., v HOMEYER, MICHAEL295.1CA 12-01891(2008-3037)
LINER, JOSHUA v ARTUS, DALE503.1TP 12-01704(446-2012)
M., ARIANNA, MTR. OF304CAF 12-00442(NA-2258-10, NA-2259-10)
MALESA, WALTER P. v BURG, KRISTI M.334CA 12-01707(2009-9163)
MANUFACTURERS AND TRADERS TRUST CO., MTR. OF306CA 12-01798(1980-DT-0125/A)
MARROW, DEBORAH E. v STATE OF NEW YORK,241CA 12-00974(111701)
MARTINEZ, GILBERTO AGUDO v REMBERT, APRIL M.374CA 12-00260(AP11/0080)
MARTINEZ, ERIC X., PEOPLE v527KA 12-00341(I11-01-051)
MENTER, STEPHEN F. v CITY OF OLEAN,308CA 12-01304(77600)
MICHAEL MIRAN, PH.D. PSYCHOLGIST,, P.C., PEOPLE v321KA 12-01198(2009-0535C-A)
MIRAN, MICHAEL, PEOPLE v319KA 12-01189(I2009-0535A-A)
MIRAN, ESTA, PEOPLE v320KA 12-01197(I2009-0535B-A)
MONARCH COMPANIES, INC., v DELAWARE NORTH COMPANIES,562CA 12-02064(I2012-2757)
MONETTE, ROBERT K. v TRUMMER, CHRISTINA L.79CA 12-01274(75875)
MUNN, JEREL J., PEOPLE v522KA 11-01651(I2010-2255)
NELSON, JR., GERALD L., PEOPLE v278KA 11-01986(I10-10-197)
NEW YORK MUNICIPAL INSURANCE, RECIPROCAL v CASELLA CONSTRUCTION, INC.,399CA 12-02094(09-1718)
O'CONNELL, DANIEL v O'CONNELL, MARY232CAF 12-01649(V-17831-10/10A)
OLUFSEN, BRADLEY v PLUMMER, TRICIA350CAF 12-00335(V-13008-09)
P., DARRYL, PEOPLE v395KA 10-01178(II-2009-0727-1-V)
PAGE, CORLAN, PEOPLE v256KA 07-01852(I1708-2002)
PALLADIAN HEALTH, LLC, v SUMMER STREET CAPITAL II, L.P.,400CA 12-01351(2011-601679)
PASSALACQUA, JOSHUA v STATE OF NEW YORK,458CA 12-02102(120604)
PRIMAKOV, PAVEL, PEOPLE v300KA 09-00283(I2007-1045)
PUTRELO CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, v TOWN OF MARCY,312CA 12-01082(CA2007-000006)
RAAB, JAMIE v KALEIDA HEALTH,34CA 12-00864(2006-004013)
RICE, CATHERINE v MILLS, MICHAEL E.494CAF 12-00597(V-02693-02/11E)
RICE, MARIA A., PEOPLE v417KA 06-02294(I2006-0056)
RIGBY, DALE R., PEOPLE v261KA 11-01661(I2009-098)
RIVERA, STEVEN, PEOPLE v203KA 08-01758(I2007-0876B)
ROMAN, JUAN, PEOPLE v437KA 11-02601(5416)
ROSKWITALSKI, MATTHEW J. v FLEMING, CATHERINE D.370CAF 12-01090(V-11582-07/11C)
ROSSBOROUGH, RONALD D., PEOPLE v112KA 11-01860(SSCI10-074)
RUMSEY, JEFFREY, PEOPLE v465KA 10-00815(I2009-186W)
SABINO, SAUL v HULIHAN, WILLIAM F.361TP 12-01155(2011-1046)
SAFADJOU, SAMAN v MOHAMMADI, AZINE358CA 12-00270(2009-17974)
SAFADJOU, SAMAN v MOHAMMADI, AZINE359CA 12-00271(2009-17974)
SAFADJOU, SAMAN v MOHAMMADI, AZINE357CA 12-00269(2009-17974)
SAID, RICHARD A., PEOPLE v297KA 11-01644(I2009-02189I)
SAID, RICHARD A., PEOPLE v296KA 11-01643(I2009-00388I)
SCHMIDT, JESSICA M. v GUENTHER, TINA M.240CA 12-01630(141356)
SMITH, PAUL J. v NESTLE PURINA PETCARE COMPANY,266CA 12-01554(K1-2007-435)
SPAULDING, THOMAS R. v LOOMIS MASONRY, INC.,32CA 12-01395(2010-2238)
STATE OF NEW YORK, v BRUSSO, DONALD375CA 11-02586(2010/16159)
STOVCSIK, CHRISTINE A. v CONESUS LAKE NURSING HOME, LLC,246CA 12-01073(1475-2010)
SWINDON, JAY, PEOPLE v411KA 10-00504(I2009-0581-1)
T., DONIELE J. v G., CLAIR H.468CAF 11-02150(V-01360-01/10L)
THOMAS, CHESTER J. v SMITH, GABRIELLE C.301CAF 12-00498(8400/03-07/11F)
TIEDE, TONYA v FRONTIER SKYDIVERS, INC.,215CA 12-01857(I2011-1523)
TIEDE, TONYA v FRONTIER SKYDIVERS, INC.,216CA 12-01861(I2011-1523)
TRG ADVISORS, INC., v P&A RETIREMENT PLAN SERVICES, INC,500CA 12-01472(I-2012-000556)
TRG ADVISORS, INC., v P&A RETIREMENT PLAN SERVICES, INC,499CA 12-01124(I-2012-000556)
TROMBLEY, JR., DOUGLAS A., PEOPLE v388KA 12-00599(I2011-092)
TROTT, JEROME, PEOPLE v344KA 11-01224(I2010-1640)
TSOULIS, ALEXANDROS v ABBOTT BROS. II STEAK OUT, INC.,214CA 12-00708(103322)
VITRAN EXPRESS, INC., v F&W TRANSPORT SERVICES, INC.,475CA 12-01558(2010/4745)
W., AIDEN J., MTR. OF133CAF 11-01240(B-01013-10)
WASHINGTON, JOSEPH, PEOPLE v484KA 12-00132(I2009-0119D)
WELCH, ELBERT v STATE OF NEW YORK,480CA 11-01784(113903)
WEST, JAMES M. v SHEAHAN, MICHAEL435TP 12-02002(46455)
WILLIAMS, ERIC P., PEOPLE v364KA 12-00370(I5448.1)
WILLIS, JR., RODNEY W., PEOPLE v299KA 11-00342(S08-50)
YOUNG, WILLIE J. v BAUERLEIN, RONALD K.376CA 12-01927(2009-009490)
ZGODA-MARTIN, LINDA v LIBERATORE, VICTOR243CA 12-01575(K1-2008-1096)
    
 MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS