At a Special Term of the Supreme
Court, held in and for the County
of Chautauqua, State of New York,
held at the Chautauqua County
Courthouse in the Village of
Mayville, New York, on the 18th
day of September, 1995.
PRESENT: HONORABLE JOSEPH GERACE, J.S.C.
STATE OF NEW YORK
SUPREME COURT: COUNTY OF CHAUTAUQUA
____________________________________
CHERYL ANDREA
and JOHN S. ANDREA, et al
ORDER
Plaintiffs,
vs Index #H-10610
E.I. DuPONT DE NEMOURS & CO., et al
Defendants.
____________________________________
The Defendant, Service Master Company, Inc., by their
attorneys, Hinshaw & Culbertson, having duly moved this
Court for an Order trifurcating the discovery and trials of
these actions, and to consolidate these actions for
purposes of discovery and trial, and the motion having
regularly come on to be heard;
NOW, upon reading and filing Defendant, Service
Master's, Notice of Motion to Trifurcate, dated August 11,
1995, and the Memorandum of Law in support thereof, dated
August 11, 1995; and upon Defendant, Service Master's,
Notice of Motion to Consolidate, dated September 8, 1995,
and the Affidavit of Marjorie G. Gottlieb, Esq., dated
September 8, 1995, in support thereof, and upon Defendant,
DAP, Inc.'s, Cross-Notice of Motion to Trifurcate, dated
September 1, 1995, and the Affirmation of Laurie Styka
Bloom, Esq., dated September 1, 1995, in support thereof;
and upon the Affidavit of Diane F. Bosse, Esq., attorney
for Defendant, Kings Heating & Sheet Metal, Inc., dated
September 11, 1995, in support thereof, and upon the
Affidavit and Memorandum of Law of Pamela L. Neubeck, Esq.,
attorney for Plaintiffs, dated September 11, 1995, in
opposition of Defendants' Motion to Trifurcate; and upon
the Affidavit of Leo T. Fabrizi, Esq., attorney for
Defendant, Henderson-Johnson, Inc., dated September 1,
1995, in opposition to Defendants' Motion to Trifurcate;
and upon the Affidavit and Memorandum of Law of Suzanne P.
Stearn, Esq., attorney for Defendant, Jamestown Public
Schools, dated September 13, 1995, in opposition to
Defendant's Motion to Consolidate; and various counsel for
the parties have appeared before this Court; and after due
deliberation having been had thereon, it is:
ORDERED, that Defendant, Service Master's, Motion to
Trifurcate is hereby adjourned until June 24, 1996, but may
be heard sooner if parties agree; and it is further
ORDERED, that Defendant, Service Master's, Motion to
Consolidate all of the cases for purposes of trial is
denied; and it is further
ORDERED, that the cases entitled Andrea,etal.vs
E.I.DuPontdeNemours&Co., et al; Francisco,etal.vs
JamestownPublicSchools; Dietz,etal.vsJamestownPublic
Schools; and Seekings,etal.vsJamestownPublicSchools,
shall be consolidated for purposes of discovery; and it is
further
ORDERED, that a schedule for completion of discovery
in these cases is established as follows:
a. November15,1995: All Plaintiffs' counsel are
to serve demands for settlement on the Defendants
and their counsel and to the Court;
b. November30,1995: Plaintiffs' first set of
written discovery demands are to be served on
Defendants;
c. December15,1995: Defendants' counsel are to
meet in Buffalo, New York, to discuss discovery,
settlement demands and other logistical matters,
and counsel are to consider dividing up the
Defendants into groups of Defendants, so that
liaison counsel for each group may be appointed
for purposes of notice and receipt of notice, with
the results of this meeting to be reported to the
Court by telephone by December 15, 1995.
d. January30,1996: Defendants are to serve
responses to Plaintiffs' written discovery demands
on or before this date;
e. BetweenJanuary31,1996andMay30,1996: All
parties are to take the depositions of non-party,
non-medical witnesses within this time period, and
said depositions are to take place on Tuesday,
Wednesday, and Thursday of the third week of each
month, beginning February, 1996, or at such other
times as the parties may agree;
f. BetweenMay31,1996andNovember30,1996:
Depositions of Defendants' witnesses,
representatives and/or former employees are to
take place in this time period, and that said
depositions are to take place on Tuesday,
Wednesday, and Thursday of the third week of each
month, or as agreed to by the parties;
g. February28,1997: Plaintiffs shall identify
their causation experts and answer expert witness
discovery on or before this date;
h. February28,1997: Plaintiffs are to amend their
Complaint and/or Bill of Particulars on or before
this date;
i. June30,1997: Defendants must complete
depositions and provide expert witness disclosure
on or before this date;
and it is further
ORDERED, that the parties are required to report back
to the Court on the status of these cases at such times as
the Court shall so determine; and it is further
ORDERED, that after November 30, 1996, the Court will
consider Motions to Dismiss or Motions for Summary Judgment
by any defendant and after February 28, 1997 the scheduling
of depositions of the plaintiffs, health care providers,
and plaintiffs' causation experts and the scheduling of
expert witness disclosure by the defendants shall be taken
up at a status conference to be scheduled by the Court and
counsel.
Dated: November , 1995
Mayville, New York
____________________________
JOSEPH GERACE
Supreme Court Justice