Decisions 2003–2004
Description
These opinions are uncorrected and subject to revision in the Official Reports. These opinions are not available for publication in any official or unofficial reports, except the New York Law Journal, without approval of the State Reporter or the Committee on Opinions (22 NYCRR 7300.1)
Decisions 2003–2004
Adler v. Columbia Sav. & Loan Ass'n (J. Polizzi) (Sept. 26,2003) Index No. 223/1987
Agway/Countryway Insurance v. Deleon (J. Rios) (Sep. 9, 2004) Index No. 26187/03
Alarcon v. Stahl York Ave. Co. (J. Taylor) (June 16, 2003) Index No. 2624/1998
Angelopoulos v. Angelopoulos (J. Gartenstein) (Oct. 21, 2003) Index No. 12229/01
Archer v. Wall St. Bath and Health Club (J. Polizzi) (Nov. 10, 2004) Index No. 7690
Auciello v. Eustaquio (J. Polizzi) (Oct. 19, 2004) Index No. 22527/2002
Audax v. MTA (J. Polizzi) (Jul. 8, 2003) Index No. 28888/99
Augustine v. Sugrue (J. Taylor) (April 30, 2003) Index No. 13376/01
Ballos, Matter of (J. Satterfield) (July 11, 2003) Index No. 5307/2003
Bantum v. American Stock Exchange (J. Dollard) (April 3, 2003) Index No. 23099/2002
Belle Harbor Washington Hotel v. Jefferson Omega Corp. (J. Taylor) (Apr. 27, 2004) Index No. 3175/2004
Benjamin of Forest Hills Realty v. Austin Sheppard Realty (J. Dorsa) (Nov. 23, 2004) Index No. 28032/98
Bethco Corp. v. Tweedy (J. Dorsa) (Dec. 15, 2004) Index No. 11005/04
Bhattacharyya v. Quincy Mutual Fire Ins. (J. Price) (Dec. 15, 2004) Index No. 21398/03
Biondo v. Travelers Indemnity Co. (J. Taylor) (Aug. 5, 2003) Index No. 9092/1997
Boccia v. Murphy (J. Price) (Dec. 4, 2003) Index No. 4598/1995
Bobadilla v. NYS Div. of Housing & Comm. Renewal (J. Hart) (Feb. 4, 2004) (Index No. 18077/2003) (Motion Cal. No. 6)
Bobadilla v. NYS Div. of Housing & Comm. Renewal (J. Hart) (Feb. 4, 2004) (Index No. 18077/2003) (Motion Cal. No. 7)
Brandes v. North Shore Univ. Hospital (J. Weiss) Index No. 5965/1997
Brennan v. R. C. Dolner, Inc. (J. Hart) Index No. 88/2001
Brogdan v. Sheridan (J. Schulman) (Jul. 23, 2004) Index No. 1324/04
Brown v. Brown (J. Polizzi) (Aug. 11, 2003) Index No. 29004/2001
Cammarata v. Drexel (J. Kitzes) (May. 5, 2004) Index No. 9857/02
Canawill v. Nastasi (J. Kitzes) (Mar. 30, 2004) Index No. 29650/2001
Casa de Cambio Delgado v. Casa de Cambio Puebla (J. Polizzi) (May 7, 2003) Index No. 25236/2002
Chand v. Asghar (J. Polizzi) (Oct. 26, 2004) Index No. 3099/00
Chand v. City of New York (J. Elliot) (Dec. 14, 2004) Index No. 29478/02
Charles v. Highland Care Center (J. Schulman) (Nov. 17, 2004) Index No. 16357/01
Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corp. v. Nieves (J. Price) (Oct. 5, 2004) Index No. 3453/01
Clancy v. Sterling Doubleday Enterprises, LP (J. Price) (March 16, 2004) Index No. 18714/01
Cohen v. Egelman (J. Kelly) (Dec. 14, 2004) Index No. 12677/00
Corredine v. VW Credit, Inc. (J. Hart) (Oct. 7, 2004) Index No. 24002/2002
Cossentino v. Weinstein (J. O'Donoghue) (Dec. 1, 2004) Index No. 10879/2004
Country-Wide Ins. Co. v. Marcano (J. Hart) (Apr. 7, 2004) Index No. 11740/2003
Country-Wide Ins. Co. v. Rashed (J. Hart) (Sept. 16, 2003) Index No. 9252/2003
Cypress Hills Cemetery v. City of New York (J. Satterfield) (Aug. 7, 2003) Index No. 3267/2003
Davis v. Elmhurst Dairy (J. Hart) (Feb 3, 2004) Index No. 2490/2002
Dermigny v. Dermigny (J. Gartenstein) (Feb. 2, 2004) Index No. 13078/99
Devora Jewelry v. Davis Alarm (J. Dollard) (Apr. 16, 2003) Index No. 5688/03
Diaz, Matter of (J. Taylor) (Feb. 17, 2004) Index No. 6651/1999
Dun-Zheng Yan v. Klein (J. Grays) (Oct. 15, 2003) Index No. 8004/2003
Earle v. Gangadeen (J. Taylor) (March 7, 2003) Index No. 30493/2002
Engel v. Forest Hills Gardens Corp. (J. Weiss) (March 7, 2003) Index No. 19868/99
Fang v. Heng Sang Realty Corp. (J. Hollie) (Aug. 6, 2003) Index No. 19255/96
Fleurentin v. Fleurentin (J. Morgenstern) (Jul. 7, 2004) Docket No. O-14599-03/3A, O-00122-04/04A
Frank v. Mazs Group, LLC. (J. Hart) (Feb. 4, 2004) Index No. 22191/2003
Gardner v. Frantz, Next Generation Limo, Nationwide Assurance (J. Satterfield) (Jul. 14, 2004) Index No. 19254/02
Gelmart v. Hubert (J. Grays) Index No. 1007/2002
Goodman v. Goodman (J. Gavrin) (Jan. 2, 2003) Index No. 17864/99
Granshaw v. Granshaw (J. Gartenstein) (Jul. 7, 2004) Index No. 8506/92
Greenpoint Savings Bank v. Papoutsakis (J. Spitzer) (Aug. 2, 2004) Index No. 24907/02
Harris v. Harris (J. Dorsa) (Feb. 14, 2003) Index No. 27079/00
Hartford Accident v. Rose (J. Rios) (Oct. 13, 2004) Index No. 306/04
Hennessey v. 91 American Grocery (J. Taylor) (March 14, 2003) Index No. 28390/2000
Hwang v. Hwang (J. Lebowitz) (June 8, 2004) Index No. 6038/98
Jacobs v. Bloomingdale's (J. Taylor) (May 6, 2003) Index No. 017283/1996
JFK International Air Terminal v. NYS Dept. Taxation & Finance (J.Hart) (March 3, 2003) Index No. 25816/2002
Joline v. NYC (J. Elliot) (Mar. 25, 2004) Index No. 16528/01
Kaiser & Wehlou v. Forest Hills Gardens Assoc. (J. Polizzi) (June 1, 2004) Index No. 7126/2004
Khaldarov v. Neighborhood Housing NYC (J. Kelly) (Mar. 2, 2004) Index No. 553/2004
Kim v. Kim (J. Gartenstein) (Mar. 28, 2003) Index No. 25154/01
Knight v. Dawson (J. Polizzi) (Jul. 6, 2004) Index No. 24577
Koudellou v. Sakalis (J. Grays) (Dec. 8, 2004) Index No. 25156/02
Kwack v. Gross (J. Hart) (Sep. 8, 2004) Index No. 4395/2001
Langdale Owners Corp. v. United Contracting Services of NY Corp. (J. Glover) (Feb. 21,2003) Index No. 23960/2002
Lawrence v. Kuo (J. Dollard) (Aug. 20, 2004) Index No. 26597/01
Lee v. Reyes (J. Glover) (Mar. 10, 2003) Index No. 22545/02
Lees v. Colin Service Systems (J. Schulman) (Jul. 21, 2004) Index No. 15559/02
Li v. Akhtar (J. Hart) (Jun. 2, 2004) Index No. 26044/03
Liberty Mutual v. Tigre (J. Rios) (Sep. 1, 2004) Index No. 14682/04
Lowe v. NYS Div. Housing & Community Renewal (J. Hart) (May. 19, 2004) Index No. 10837/03
Marca v. St. John's University (J. Grays) (Oct. 5, 2004) Index No. 29928/03
Matter of Cohen (J. Weiss) (Jan. 13, 2003) Index No. 23774/02
Matter of Ficalora (J. Taylor) (Dec. 1, 2003) Index No. 7042/2002
Matter of Jackson (J. Thomas) (Jan. 29, 2003) Index No. 31313/01
Mc Rae v. Jennings (J. Taylor) (Aug. 13, 2003) Index 17625/03
Mirelle v. Renol (J. Morgenstern) (Jul. 7, 2004) Docket No. O-15899-03/3A, Docket No. O-00122-04/04A
Moore v. Jamaica Buses, Inc. (J. Satterfield) (Aug. 11, 2003) Index No. 4355/2003
Mughal v. Yaqoob (J. Weiss) (Sep. 1, 2004) Index No. 25585/03
Nastasi v. Nastasi III (J. Kitzes) (Dec. 18, 2003) Index No. 22427/03
Natural Stone Industries, Inc. v. Utica National Assurance Co. (J. Hart) (Nov. 8, 2004) Index No. 18528/03
NJ Re-Insurance v. Intriago (J. Rios) (Jun. 16, 2004) Index No. 3096/04
NYC v. Blount (J. Flaherty) (Mar. 11, 2004) Index No. 1096-94
NYS Correctional Officers & PBA v. Straub (J. Weiss) (Aug. 18, 2004) Index No. 14585/04
O'Neal v. NYC Housing Authority (J. Hart) (Jan. 3, 2003) Index No. 4143/98
OTC Int'l, LTD v. Lloyd's of London (J. Thomas) Index No. 32209/01
Paniccia vs. NY/NJ Port Authority (J. Grays) (Nov. 3, 2004) Index No. 5103/2002
People v. Adames (J. Kohm) (March 29, 2004) Indict. No. 3891/02
People v. Boehm (J. Rotker) [Plea Withdrawal] (Aug. 30, 2004) Indict. No. 921-03
People v. Barton (J. Rotker) (April 30, 2003) Indict. No. 03837/2002
People v. Brathwaite (J. Goldstein) (April 2, 2004) Indict. No. 5068/91 & Indict. No. 2741/92
People v. Brown (J. Rotker) (July 30, 2003) Indict. No. 4176-2002
People v. Bussey (J. Spires) Indict. No. 1047/1999
People v. Campbell (J. Rotker) (April 30, 2003) Indict. No. 197/2003
People v. Carrieri (J. Buchter) (April 15, 2004) Index No. 1625-01
People v. Chambers (J. Erlbaum) (May 27, 2004) Indict. No. 1309/2002
People v. Conyers (J. Rosenzweig) (May 10, 2004) Indict. No. 703/2003
People v. Dasque (J. Roman) (Jan. 13, 2004) Indict. No. 3311/01
People v. E.C. (J. Blumenfeld) (April 4, 2003) Indict. No. QN10525-2002
People v. Fermin (J. Grosso) (Aug. 16, 2004) Indict. No. 2781/03, Indict. No. 2835/03
People v. Fields (J. Rotker) (June 15, 2004) Indict. No. N10180-02
People v. Khan (J. Rotker) (June 23, 2004) Indict. No. 499-90
People v. Kimyagarova (J. Cooperman) (Sept. 13, 2004) Indict. No. 1914/03
People v. Largo (J. Roman) (Dec. 1, 2004) Ind. No. 291/97
People v. Palmer (J. Rotker) (Sept. 30, 2003) Indict. No. 0197/2003
People v. Peetz (J. Rotker) (June 7, 2004) Indict. No. 574/95
People v. Powell (J. Kohm) (May 8, 2003) Indict. No. 10946-02
People v. Rawlings (J. Kohm) (Sept. 13, 2004) Indict. No. 2924/1988
People v. Sawyer (J. Rosenzweig) (Feb. 6, 2003) Indict. No. 2687/02
People v. Smaldone (J. McDonald) (June 30, 2001) Indict. No. 7708-91
People v. Stennett (J. Rotker) (May 28, 2004) Indict. No. N10590-03
People v. Stephans (J. Grosso) (Dec. 3, 2003) Indict. No. N10344/2003
People v. Torres (J. O'Dwyer) (Oct. 30, 2003) Indict. No. 3727-02
People v. Torres (J. Rotker) (Sept. 14, 2004) Indict. No. 1812-04
People v. Uboh (J. Rotker) (Jul. 14, 2004) Indict. No. 909-96
People v. Yaldizian (J. Rotker) (Sept. 7, 2004) Indict. No. 1768-03
People v. Zambrano (J. Rotker) (Nov. 24, 2003) Indict. No. 00208-03
Plumbing Solutions, Ltd. v. Werzberger (J. Hart) (Apr. 14, 2004) Index No. 2525
Realm National Insurance Co. v. NYS Worker's Compensation Board (J. Kelly) (Mar. 11, 2004) Index No. 18436/2003
Reaves v. NYC Housing Authority (J. Taylor) (June 15, 2004) Index No. 8088/2004
Reiff v. P.S. Marcato Elevator Co. (J. Taylor) (Sep. 7, 2004) Index No. 11235/2001
Rivera v. Green Acres Mall (J. Taylor) (Mar. 21, 2003) Index No. 15092/1998
Rodriguez v. Park City (J. Hart) (Dec. 15, 2004) Index No. 4882/2000
Rubenfeld v. Kelly (J. Goldstein) (Sept. 2, 2003) Index No. 42/2003
Ryder v. Lopez (J. Dollard) (May. 11, 2004) Index No. 11509/2000
S.C. v. A.C (J. Lebowitz) (Jun. 17, 2004) Index No. 19650/02
Sabbatini v. Galati (J. Hart) (Nov. 12, 2003) Index No. 8546
San Sung Korean Methodist Church v. Professional USA (J. Dollard) (Feb. 5, 2004) Index No. 6613/2003
Scanlon v. Lippman (J. Hart) Index No. 5508/03
Snapper Realty v. Duane Reade (J. Dollard) (Apr. 1, 2003) Index No. 2869/03
State Farm Mutual v. Lumbermans Mutual (J. Rios) (Jul. 16, 2004) Index No. 1144/04
Stuart v. NYC Health & Hospitals Corp. (J. Kitzes) (Jan. 5, 2004) Index No. 9767/03
Sullivan v. S.P. (J. Satterfield) Index No. 500395/04
Suarez v. Tertipis (J. Kitzes) (Jun. 6, 2004) Index No. 924/02
Surillo v. Dollar Rent-A-Car (J. Weiss) (Jun. 16, 2004) Index No. 13199/02
Taylor v. Hildebrandt (J. Weiss) (Jun. 9, 2004) Index No. 1162/03
Tucker v. Weich (J. Satterfield) (July 9, 2003) Index No. 5054/03
Ungureanu v. Battaglia (J. Kitzes) (Jan 9, 2004) Index No. 25452/03
Union Plaza Nursing Home v. Pao (J. Kitzes) (May. 26, 2004) Index No. 27844/2003
Universal Express, Inc. v. McKinnon (J. Dollard) (Oct. 31, 2004) Cal. No.: 53
Utica Mutual v. Munoz (J. Rios) (Aug. 18, 2004) Index No. 10798/03
Vasquez v. Vasquez (J. Strauss) (Nov. 24, 2003) Index No. 3631/03
Williams v. New Style Limousine, Inc. (J. Ritholtz) Index No. 1717/00
Wojtowicz v. New York & Harlem R.R. Co. (J. Hart) Index No. 820/2003
Wu v. Wu (J. Schulman) (Sep. 14, 2004) Index No. 11756/1999
Yan v. Klein and Diamond (J. Grays) Index No. 8004/03
Yavne v. Statman (J. Hart) Index No. 27553
Yu v. NYU Medical Center (J. Roman) (June 3, 2004) Index No. 8657/01
